"Anything that was shiny or painted didn't go anywhere near the melt when I was putting up ingots"? Careful the Zn monster can live in your culling criteria and the grayish silver lead ones melt just fine keeping the never exceed temps and diagonal cutters keep as your friends. Advice is like, well you've heard it I'm sure. But as hard/critical as you seem to be on yourself- experiment for FUN. Try another source of lead, pot at 725, pre-heat mold or cast till you get frosty and then ease up on the gas just a touch with maybe just a little smaller sprue- just for fun.