So I've been working my search skills and doing lots of reading and I ran across this recipe. To anyone else new looking for a lube without a ton of ingredients try this out: 3 parts beeswax 1 part synthetic 2 cycle. I happened to also have a quart of homelite for wood season sitting around so I used that. Works perfect just melt and mix. No fuss recipe that works great.
It's a nice firm lube that works great and is really no more tacky when dry than beeswax. I think I'll be using this going forward and use my previous experiments as flux.