I've done it in plastic tubs and it worked okay. I was wondering if it would be worth it to get a small, cheap crockpot (about $10 new) to cook the brass in citric acid. What do you think?
I've done it in plastic tubs and it worked okay. I was wondering if it would be worth it to get a small, cheap crockpot (about $10 new) to cook the brass in citric acid. What do you think?
Not worth it.
I would think that agitation would be better than just heat.
But for a $10 experiment, let us know how it went.
TEAM HOLLYWOOD
NRA- LIFE TSRA-LIFE SASS-LIFE
Never really needed heat when I tried. But got sick of the "work" and gave up on getting them spotless. I've found they don't shoot better when clean on the inside/primer pocket (which inthe only benefit IMO for vib vs wet). So I took my money and picked up a lyman tumbler and never looked back (like$30-40 maybe)
Mind you these are my personal experiences. 90% target handgun loads as small about of bench shooting.
I jsut use plastic tubs for wet cleaning with lemi shine dawn dish soap. Let it soak for 45 mins or so in hot water. I use the mr coffe for the hot water. Then set out to dry and a little time in the vibraator polisher and they come out beter than new.
You might find a one quart pyrex sauce pan and warm the solution with a hot plate or a hair dryer.
EDG
I've had good luck using very hot water for the citric acid, and have an old crock pot that I was allowed to "liberate."
I used a plastic container inside, surrounded with water, so that I could easily remove the brass or clean out the acid.
Worked alright.
I had hoped to get the mix boiling, and have the agitation help mechanically loosen the crud, but citric acid doesn't boil until
590 °F so even in my weak solution it raised the boiling point higher than the crock pot could produce. Going by memory, but I think the crockpot is 150 Watts.
I had a batch of brass in solution heating in the pot for about an hour, trying to get it to boil. It was maybe a touch cleaner then brass sitting in very hot(just boiled) water and citric acid for 10 minutes. The only noticeable difference was the longer soak time loosen primer pocket grunge enough that it would wipe out with a piece of paper towel on a pocket brush.
As I still had to use the brush, I don't see as big an advantage as there would be with stainless pins, but the brass sure was clean. Just another excuse to play mad scientist.
I just ran a batch through the Crock Pot citric acid bath and then through the vibratory tumbler with Lizard Litter and a bit of Iosso case brite. The cases weren't quite as clean as the ones I have seen done in SS media, but they came close. I like using the crock pot because the solution stays hot. I stir a couple of times with a slotted spoon. This even gets those real nasty looking pieces of range brass bright and shiny.
Is it necessary? I really don't know. But you can pick up a crock pot at a yard sale or thrift store for next to nothing.
A vote for anyone other then the conservative candidates is a vote for the liberal candidates.
Just like any reloading equipment/tool if you think you will like it (it makes you happy), or if it makes your brass processing easier, do it! Personal preference is the deciding factor in a whole lot of reloading, casting, brass processing practices. I don't use citric acid. Not because I don't think it'll work, but my preferred method for cleaning brass is walnut shells in an old rotary tumbler. Just like my preference for mixed brass vs. sorted by headstamp, primer pocket cleaning, and primer pocket crimp removal will differ from a lot of reloaders. Crock pot for liquid brass cleaning? Do it!
My Anchor is holding fast!
I buy the lowest price w/free shipping food-grade citric acid powder on ebay. $10 worth lasts me over a year. Use about a t-spoon in 2 qts hot tap water in a mop bucket. I soak for 20 min and maybe agitate with my hand twice. I use the same solution for several different calibers of brass one after the other on a given day. Rinse thoroughly and dry in the sun on a screen wire rack. Works like a charm and plenty shiny for me.
Went to an estate sale last week and bought a box of household/garage chemicals for 5 bucks...lo and behold in the box was 2 one pound containers of RX grade citric acid. Should last awhile.
Mr. Ed
The only good cast boolit is the one that hits the target
My wife gave me a brand new little crock pot to use. I've done one small batch of rifle shell with about 30 .45acp cases. They were dull, but not range pickup dirty. After citric treatment, I dried them and gave them about 40 minutes +-in the FA vibrator. Came out really nice.
I hope there is a gun range in heaven, otherwise I'm going to hell!
I think a cheap ultrasonic cleaner would be money better spent.
Short answer is no!! Plastic tub or bucket is fine
Long, Wide, Deep, and Without Hesitation!
To test this you need a control. Make three piles of dirty brass, apply different treatments, observe results.
I suspect that citric acid helps just a little with cleaning and a lot with removing oxidation, making the brass sparkle more for the same amount of clean.
I tumble with pins but have been thinking about a tall tank built from 12” pvc with forced air to keep the brass moving. Probably not gonna work, but I like the idea of hitting a button and having it run, drain, rinse, drain, and be done.
If your reloading projects haven't been banned from the kitchen like mine--
Get a $2 pot from Goodwill and use the stove.
I used to use the oven to dry soap & water washed brass.
After the 2nd live .45ACP got in there and cooked off---
all ammunition related stuff was banned from the kitchen.
Last edited by Winger Ed.; 11-12-2019 at 10:14 PM.
In school: We learn lessons, and are given tests.
In life: We are given tests, and learn lessons.
OK People. Enough of this idle chit-chat.
This ain't your Grandma's sewing circle.
EVERYONE!
Back to your oars. The Captain wants to waterski.
Just use the stove. If you don’t want to do that get a Colman stove. Use outside in a open garage. Every body should have one. I have all electric and every 10 years or so the power goes out but I can still cook. Just use the kitchen stove in a big stainless pot from good will. Use a slotted spoon and stir every once in awhile. Dump in a colander in the sink and rinse and done
Shinny brass ALWAYS shoots better!
Or is it just me
BP | Bronze Point | IMR | Improved Military Rifle | PTD | Pointed |
BR | Bench Rest | M | Magnum | RN | Round Nose |
BT | Boat Tail | PL | Power-Lokt | SP | Soft Point |
C | Compressed Charge | PR | Primer | SPCL | Soft Point "Core-Lokt" |
HP | Hollow Point | PSPCL | Pointed Soft Point "Core Lokt" | C.O.L. | Cartridge Overall Length |
PSP | Pointed Soft Point | Spz | Spitzer Point | SBT | Spitzer Boat Tail |
LRN | Lead Round Nose | LWC | Lead Wad Cutter | LSWC | Lead Semi Wad Cutter |
GC | Gas Check |