A little over 40 years back is when I began my handgun shooting and reloading. Like many others, I'd always had a handgun around in some shape, form or fashion. I was already a huge fan of Skeeter Skelton, Bill Jordan and a couple of others. Then I discovered Ed McGivern. I began reloading and shooting as much as I could. In short, a Smith & Wesson revolver is what I cut my teeth on when it comes to handgun work. Later in life, I took to the 1911 and learned it inside out. I would feel comfortable with either for a defensive situation if it were to arise. Which is hopefully never.
Back about 15-16 years ago, I was introduced to IDPA shooting. They held matches in a town about 60 miles away once a month on Sundays. I figured to give it a try. After I had a few matches under my belt I decided (and hoped) I would like to shoot both in the same match. The host club and range officials had no problem with it. So, between stages I'd swap gear and have a second go at the course. I kept records of all those matches for a year. Some matches, I came out ahead shooting a K frame Model 19, other times it was with my 1911. Finally, I had a year of matches I'd kept records of. I sat down and did the math. I was a little surprised, then again I wasn't for some odd reason. The numbers showed I was slightly faster and more accurate with my revolver than my 1911.
That being said. Give me a good ole' Model 10 & 3 molds. A lightweight 125 grain for critter control and other light chores, something in the 150-160 grain for all around shooting. And lastly, a Keith mold in 172 grains. Those 3 molds, some Bullseye and Unique powder and I'd feel just fine with it. I also have to agree with Texas By God. A Model 10 spirited away in every room is as good a plan as any. Right up until I get to my Benelli Super 90 with a 2 shot extension.
Murphy