PayPal did this to me in the past, Willy was kind enough to deal with this personally, amidst all the chaos he was dealing with already. This time I'm letting it ride as-is rather than ask Willy to try and fix PayPal's theft.
Thanks for last time, Willy. You were above and beyond.
Anywho, PayPal refuses to address this issue, instead blaming 'Castboolits'.