The lugs looked pretty good actually, the edge wasn't sharp like a new one, but not really rounded. For $200, i figured it was worth it just for the comp, it came home with me. It doesn't fit my slide, as the threaded part was machined down a little further, so with the comp fitted, it doesn't sit quite deep enough. I may try and remove the comp so i can wind it back a turn or two to give clearance. Once i get my new one fitted, this one may become my fun play barrel, not sure for what just yet, but one that won't make me sad if something was to happen to it.