Same or Different - Super Durable Wet Black from PBTP and APP

[rototerrier]

Curious if the super durable wet black from Powder by the Pound and AllPowderPaints is the same or different?

Anyone tried both? Forum posts suggest both work fine for ASBBDT.

I currently have a couple pounds from PBTP and just order 2lbs from APP because it was cheaper and people said it worked.

Am I buying the same powder at a cheaper price, or are they somehow different? In a good or bad way? Or just different equal?

Looking at the 2 websites. They do differ slightly, but could they still be the same and just represented differently by each company.

Both are TGIC

PBTP:
Cure Schedule = 400f/10 Min at Part Metal Temperature
Gloss Level = 95% On 60 Degree Meter
Recommended Mil Thickness = 2.0 - 3.0 Mils.
Specific Gravity = 1.26
Theoretical Coverage = 61.0 Sq. Ft.
Salt Spray Results = 3,000+ Hours
Humidity Resistance = 1,000+ Hours

APP:
SUPER DURABLE WET BLACK
SUPER DURABLE POLYESTER TGIC
CURE TIME = 400F/10 MIN @ PMT (PART METAL TEMPERATURE)
GLOSS LEVEL = 98% (HIGH GLOSS)
SPECIFIC GRAVITY = 1.2 - 1.8
THEORETICAL COVERAGE = 51.5 SQ. FT/LB
SALT SPRAY RESULTS = 3,000+ HRS

[ryokox3]

No idea if they are the same, but I used the APP one with very good results. Thinking of it there must be some differences , kind of like trade secrets that go into each brand. Still the main thing is you will not be disappointed in the app one.

[Walter Laich]

of course the next question is what happens if you mix them together?
since mine all come from smoke I can't try this myself

[rototerrier]

Comparing them side by side, they look and spoon the same. They even use similar stickers, fonts, and packaging. If you had 2 unmarked bags side by side from both companies and their names weren't listed, you could never tell the difference.

I've not yet had a chance to coat and shoot any, but I suspect there won't be any difference at all. I'll post my results once I have some.