Several years ago I loaded up about 700 rounds of .45 ACP with a 200gr LSWC over 4.0 of Clays. Also a similar number of 200gr plated round nose over the same load.
Shot up all of the LSWC rounds over the years, and about half of the round nose rounds. Most out of a Ruger P90, with maybe 100 or so out of a Blackhawk. Never a problem.
I've recently acquired my first 1911, an RIA. I'm finding that the rounds are varying widely. Most shoot fine, but yesterday I had two failures to even operate the slide and two or three failures to fully eject (slide closed on the ejected case (not a stovepipe, the shell was in the same position as when in the chamber). Those four or five, plus several others that did run the slide had definite lower recoil impulses. One of the failures to eject was so weak that I thought it might be a squib (it wasn't, barrel was clear).
I believe my reloading procedure is sound. I load up 40-50 cases with powder, manually weighing every tenth load, and use a bright light to scan all cases in the loading block for consistent powder levels before I add bullets and seat. Taper crimp to about .469".
When I first got the RIA, I had a gunsmith replace the GI sights with sights I could actually see. He shot it with ammo I provided, as well as some of his own. He told me my loads needed more powder. I had never had that problem before with these loads, but after shooting them in the RIA, I could see why he said that. Some (but not all) of them definitely feel light. The rounds I initially gave him were not crimped as heavy. I increased the crimp on his recommendation.
Is Clays a position sensitive powder?