And you can fire 44-40 in a 45 Colt. How do I know? Why I did it myself just the other day. Several years ago I bought some ammo from a guy at a gun show that makes ammo for CAS shoots. It is all new components that are of very good quality.
This was before I started reloading myself. We were talking about the loads which is a 250 gr lead boolit with 5 grs of Bullseye.
And then we talked about me going with him on a hunt that he guides for a very reasonable price. I paid him and he handed me a bag of supposedly 50 45 colt bullets. When I got home I marked on the bag what they were with a sharpie.
Found the bag stashed the other day and since I was going to the range to try out the S&W 25-5 that I had just finished building from a parts lot, I thought I might as well shoot those.
Shot a Cylinder full of them and they were grouping about 15 inches at 10 yards. It made me think that the 25-5 was not going to be very accurate.
When I went to eject the cases from the cylinder they were really tight and hard to get out. After finally getting them out I inspected the cases and they were all bulged.
Went to look at the primer then I saw that they were 44-40 cartridges and not 45 Colt.
The guy at the gun show wasn't paying attention when he sold me what was supposedly 45 Colt cartridge's and I never looked at them after I marked what they were on the bag.
The 25-5 shoots actual 45 Colt very well though.
And it was a couple of good lessons for me too.
Don't shoot other peoples reloads, and look at the head stamp on the cartridge before you shoot one off.