Just as it says .
Parameters ;
230 gr class .
45 ACP/AR/S&W .
900-1000 fps.
Secondary hunting tool .
I have 7-8 SWC , RNFP , RB and RN in 141, 196 ,203 , 250 , 255 , 265 , 350 , and an as yet unweighed 454424 round groove HP .
Neither of the 1917s will shoot the 250-265s in a satisfactory manor , 3 alloys , WC , AC . The 265gr 452-255 RNFP shoots but doesn't make the desired 50 yd hold , a self impossed base number for standard .
Both readily meet and exceed the standard with the 200 gr class bullets .
Really I'm just going for the last ftlb in hopes I never need it .
Platforms
1917 stock
1917 Bubba'd reamed to 45 S&W aka Schofield .
HP Carbine .
M92' possible at a later time in S&W rechamber .
Yes I'm fully aware that a 230 north of 1000 fps is a hot load but I think even a weak 45 ACP action will handle a Schofield +P+ at 18-20 kpsi , standard loads are 14 kpsi , and 45 ACP is 21-23 kpsi .
I've narrowed this down to ;
Accurate 45-229N
NOE 452-228 SWC BM1
The RCBS 45-230 CB is a distant 3rd .
The 454423 is listed heavier than I want and has been noted to be irregular in weights by a wide margin .
So which and why , alternatives welcome .