I gotta tell ya, I always like to eliminate old wives tales and me being the open minded type, this one has baffled me for decades. Then the neighbor kid gave me the way to enlightenment. I gotta warn ya, if you were traumatized when you found out about Santa, then you might not want to keep reading.
This kid is one of those types that is always asking questions. One day I am wiping off my loaded rounds to put in the box and the kids asks, WHY? I just looked at my rag. What a genius! I can save a reloading step! And no more chamber cleaning. The more I thought about it, the stronger this test actually became.
Brass gives lube every advantage that a bullet can not. Especially when we make our slugs hard enough to resist obturation. Cases never move to scratch off lube compared to a bullet. Brass has more soft bearing area exposed to pressure than a bullet that only feels it on a comparatively hard base. I am NOT asking the lube to lubricate, just to seal.
To be fair, I would use a short barreled handgun so that pressure stayed up high enough to obturate the brass well until after the bullet had exited. My Whelen was also used since it is a bottle necked case in a fixed chamber. Surely the bottle necked case would seal beyond question with those pressures. I would clean after every lube.
So for the last two weeks, I tried several different types of lubes with and without lanolin, soft lubes, hard lubes at different pressure levels and quantities far more than you would find in a bore, at different temperatures.
The results were a complete and total failure. Nothing sealed or sealed better than anything else except for dried on (glued in the gun cases) LLA. And my guns, cases, and shooting bench, glasses, hands and face paid the penalty.
Strange, but as the pressure went up, dirt increased. ( ? ) Before this test, common sense would tell you that the higher pressure, the harder the brass would push out, thus requiring less of the lube to seal. Right?
So the bad news is that we still have to wipe cases and clean chambers. Needless to say, I am not happy with lube as a seal.
Was this a good test? Is it even a fair test? Is there another way?