Originally Posted by
omgb
OK, here's the story: I bought two cans of it at $28 a jug from The Gun Shop in Lancaster, ca. The firearms used were a Pedersoli Zuave, A Pedersoli Enfield two banded musket, a CVA in-line and a Knight entry level inline, a 1858 Remington .44 and a Ruger Old Army .45. All of the shooting was done over a two day stretch in the Lockwood Valley in Ventura CA. Elevation was about 4500 feet. Temps were 80 when we started at 8:30 AM on day one and peaked that same day at 95. Humidity was under 30% on day one. Day two the temps were lower and the humidity much higher at 80-90% as a weather system rolled in. Rain and lightening halted shooting at noon on day two. All of the guns were caught in the rain and soaked.
Shooting began at 8:30 am each day. Each gun was fired 5 times in a 75 minute session. We did three sessions before noon and three sessions after. The rifles were loaded with 72 grains of powder. The two .58 cal rifles used standard Minnie balls and the two inlines used Lee's 50 cal Minnie. The pistols used 30 grains of powder, round balls and standard #11 caps. Ignition was 100% in all firearms. Oh, lube was NASSA lube for the rifles and my own concoction of bee's wax, lanolin, olive oil and red crayon (for looks) in the pistols.
We had no leading and zero problems loading the guns with one exception. The Knight inline was loaded once with a Lee REAL. That took a mallet to properly seat the bullet and it produced an amazing and unexpected result. That 72 grain load made a sharp crack when fired with significantly enhanced recoil. My guess is that this load fit so tightly that it was more compressed than the others. This resulted in higher pressure and velocity...something the instruction on the Alliant web site discuss. The pistols were rather pedestrian. Kind of a dull boom rather than a sharp repot but ignition was instantaneous. Interestingly, I upped the charge to 40 grains in the ROA and substituted Lee's conical and boy-howdy did that step things up. I got a much sharper report and the hit on the gong was really hard. Not very scientific but anyone who has shot at gongs much knows when you smack one with authority and this was definitely one of those instances.
I only wiped the bore with a plastic brush once just before lunch. No wiping was required the rest of the day. At day's end a ran a patch of Butch's Bore Shine down each rifle's barrel. On the morning of the second day I ran a dry patch down each bore and snapped a cap on each nipple. The only glitch came in the Enfield. I had to pull the nipple and clean it up a bit. All was great after that. As I said, shooting was halted at noon due to a pouring rain.
I didn't get to cleaning the guns until today (12 hours later). We have been hot and very humid all week in Santa Clarita. There was light rust on the enfield band screws and some on the underside of the Zuave. No rust on either of the inlines and none on either of the pistols.
So, does this stuff warrant its price? Yes, if you need to shoot a lot without cleaning. It does require some compression to really do its best and it has an annoying habit of clinging to the inside of your measure. Geez, I had to tap it out more than once. It was accurate though and it does not promote corrosion to the same degree as Pyrodex or BP. I'm going to use it again next year.