Which is the better shell? Win AA or Fed Champion?

[sheepdog]

Win AAs or Federal Champions? I have a bunch of both but can only have room for one or the other, which should I keep?

[swheeler]

I had 1k Fed champions and they were great, but as with all paper hulls it just takes a couple loads to start burning through at the crimp. Now I suppose you have plastic ones?

[sheepdog]

I have both paper and plastic

[Bloodman14]

Keep the Win AA's!

[stubshaft]

When I was actively shooting trap I would load the Federals.

[Heavy lead]

Gold Medal? or Champions? New AA with the seperate base wad or older AA with the one piece?
Rankings the way I see them IMO:
1. Old one piece AA
2. Federal Gold Medal
3. R-P Premier STS
4. New AA with seperate base wad.
5. All the rest.
I don't like paper.

[lead Foot]

AA's and federals. I find Federal Top Gun the best all round ~ slugs, buckshot and target shot. The one with the 8 crimp.
Lead foot;

[richbug]

I like the OLD AA's and Rem STS shells the same, and rank them as #1

Feds I have trouble with the crimp opening back up over time.

The New AA's are OK

[sargenv]

Load up one and then fire and leave them lay, then keep the others ;)