PDA

View Full Version : What TRICKS are needed to successfully reload cast 9mm?



Stopsign32v
04-21-2023, 01:48 PM
Well I assumed 9mm casting reloading would be pretty straight forward but apparently from my researching it is anything but that!

So before I start I'm wondering what are some of the tricks you guys have come across that make it easier? The main issue I have been reading is of course you size your lead bullets to .357-358 and the expander die leaves the case around .356 and in turn it sizes down your lead bullet which will leave gas getting around it in the bore...yada...yada.

So far in another thread of mine a member stated his eureka moment was when he started using .38 S&W full length sizing die. I have one on the way but last night I started wondering, what will a, we will call it larger full length sizing die do to help this issue? I could understand a larger expanding die helping but what will a full length sizer do?

Then of course I've read people are using the Lee SE1699 expander plug for .38 S&W. In smaller suggestions I also saw 9x18 Makarov suggestions.


Anyways so the stage is for you guys. I'm really hoping to get some knowledge here and enjoy the journey of 9mm casting.

Lakehouse2012
04-21-2023, 02:17 PM
While there are a few tricks, 9mm isnt that difficult.

Items that work for me...: (NOTE- I am a USPSA and Steel Challenge competitor, so I have a favorite mold that I have stuffed probably +20,000 into cases)

1) Sizing projectiles at .357
2) Bevel Base mold, whether you are PC or Hitek coat, its a fairly delicate material loading into the case. BB is a huge advantage to start the process.
3) minimum bell mouthing, almost non-existent flaring of the case mouth.
4) I use a standard 9mm resize/deprime die in a progressive press. When you get around to putting projectile in, you will see case bulge. All testing I've done over the years, when I pull projectiles, they are staying at .357.
5) my lead isnt all that hard, usually 12-13brn. Typically I use range recovery and naturally is comes in around there.

Case bulge isnt an issue. While it may not look pretty, but is not affecting the shot. Keeping the interface tight is more important to me then looks. Going the other direction- with a larger sized brass and a looser connection risks gas bypass and inconsistent pressures and velocity.

Hope this helps,


Well I assumed 9mm casting reloading would be pretty straight forward but apparently from my researching it is anything but that!

So before I start I'm wondering what are some of the tricks you guys have come across that make it easier? The main issue I have been reading is of course you size your lead bullets to .357-358 and the expander die leaves the case around .356 and in turn it sizes down your lead bullet which will leave gas getting around it in the bore...yada...yada.

So far in another thread of mine a member stated his eureka moment was when he started using .38 S&W full length sizing die. I have one on the way but last night I started wondering, what will a, we will call it larger full length sizing die do to help this issue? I could understand a larger expanding die helping but what will a full length sizer do?

Then of course I've read people are using the Lee SE1699 expander plug for .38 S&W. In smaller suggestions I also saw 9x18 Makarov suggestions.


Anyways so the stage is for you guys. I'm really hoping to get some knowledge here and enjoy the journey of 9mm casting.

Lakehouse2012
04-21-2023, 02:22 PM
One additional item is actual mold.... I have tried most every mold I can for 9mm, and the one that always shows most accurate and repeatable is this one:

Miha designed this one up himself, and while it looks a bit ugly in the hand, its a GREAT performer. wibsite says it's a 135g but they always come in around 140.5g for me with RR.

https://www.mp-molds.com/product/359-135-swc-round-nose-6-cavity-mold/

metricmonkeywrench
04-21-2023, 03:10 PM
You have to hold your tongue just right….

Otherwise the 9mm is supposedly a tapered case that we’re about to stuff a straight sided bullet into it, as with about any cast bullet flaring out a case mouth a smidge to let the bullet start without shaving is the key part. Some use the Lyman “M” dies or similar and others use the standard expander. The last part is ensuring that any flare that you put in is taken out with either the seat die or a appropriate crimp die.

And hold your tongue just right

Mk42gunner
04-21-2023, 03:10 PM
Don't go looking for trouble before you even start. Load a few dummies first and see if they cycle/ chamber. If so load a few to test. Your worries may be moot; may not be either, why I suggest just loading a few.

It was in the last century (pre-internet) when I last loaded 9mm with cast (or anything else) but we just loaded and shot them. No major problems I can remember now.

Robert

whisler
04-21-2023, 07:44 PM
I had leading with my 9mm until I checked a pulled bullet and found that it was .354 in diameter. A Lee 38 S&W powder through expander plug fixed that problem and no more leading.

Hick
04-21-2023, 07:51 PM
I use a lee 356-124 truncated cone bullet and size the lead to 0.356, then powder coat to 0.358. Works quite smoothly in all my 9 mm guns (two German: a WWII P38 and post war P1, a Taurus PT-92 and a Beretta 92) The powder coating seems to solve all the issues.

higgins
04-21-2023, 08:43 PM
If you load .357-.358 bullets use a .38 spl. M-die instead of the 9mm M-die to prevent the bullet being sized down in the loading process. Slug your barrel first - you may not need to use .358 bullets. My 9mm slugs .358 in the grooves so I load an unsized Lee 358 125 gr. RNFP that drops about .359. With brass expanded with the .38 spl. M-die there's no bulge in the cases and the rounds chamber freely in my gun.

As noted above, load a couple of dummy rounds to make sure they will plunk into the chamber regardless the bullet diameter you go with.

country gent
04-21-2023, 08:56 PM
When the moon is right and you can hear an old man laughing, its time to load 9mm
Pay attention to details use the correct expander for your bullet dia. Work up the load carefully this is a small case and pressure can jump quickly. Taper crimp as this caliber head spaces on the case mouth. Plunk test the first few rounds in your barrel.
I dont find the 9mm any harder to load than 45 acp or other semi auto calibers.

hades
04-21-2023, 09:10 PM
I'm with country gent and don't find 9mm any harder to load than 45acp.


I just got a 9mm a year and a half ago (and a second 9mm last summer), and have been loading 45 since the Beginning. (My first handgun, my first cartridge reloading, and my first cast bullets).

I had dies already and naturally bought a mold for the new to me cartridge. I'm sizing the NOE 135gr RF to 0.356 and loading on a 550c with the stock dillon powder funnel and after I dialed in the taper crimp I haven't had any issues and accuracy is better than I can shoot out of 2 of my 9mms and one of my buddies doing a full load workup with a couple different powders.

I'm using a dump and stir mutt alloy around 9ish BHN, PC, and driving the 135s just over 1000fps and they shoot and feel sweet.

blue32
04-21-2023, 10:06 PM
stock dillon powder funnel

I was about to ask how in the world are you getting that to work with traditionally lubed bullets and then saw PC on the last paragraph.

Soundguy
04-21-2023, 10:23 PM
Not sure where you got your sizing info from..but they had no idea what they were doing. I size to .356 with good result. Cast requires more mouth flare than jacketed..thats also not a problem. Prime..charge..taper crimp Ang go.
As with most semi auto firearms.. Starting charges seldom perform well. Usually takes at least midrange or higher loads to get feed, stove pipe and short stroke issues to go away. One good short stroke test is to see if the bolt hold open upon empty works..if yes..you made it past the short stroke issue..etc.

I havnt found 9mm cast to be any different in difficulty than any other. 5.7-28 in cast..now that one takes work. ;)

Harter66
04-21-2023, 10:29 PM
The only trick I've used for 9mm is that my 2nd hand RCBS dies have a 38/357 expander spud .

poppy42
04-22-2023, 12:16 AM
Personally, I i’ve never had an issue loading cast in 9 mm. I can’t tell you how many thousands I cast (various different molds ), loaded, shot, out of multiple firearms. I size to 356, have superb accuracy, zero leading, out of multiple firearms, with various different boolets. My alloy is wheel weights, with a little tin added to help fill out. I have completed the NRA pistol marksmanship course all the way up to and including distinguished expert using my 9 mm Ruger SR9 with Cast Boolets. I don’t consider that some outstanding achievement it’s just some thing that I’ve done. After reading a plethora of posts about the problems that some people have loading nine I guess I’m extremely lucky I don’t know. I’m just never found it to be a problem.

GhostHawk
04-22-2023, 08:19 AM
I had 2 9mm guns that wanted to keyhole on me.

Switching from .356 to a .38 special mold that with my alloy cast at .359 solved both.

Lube needs to be up to the job.
Those loads have worked for me with Red Dot charges from 3 grains to 4.5 grains.

Both immediately showed much tighter groups and no more keyholing.

I am using the .358 125 gr plain base bullet, as cast from .359 to .3595.
Lubed with Lee Liquid Lube, 2 or 3 light light coats, dry in between in front of a fan.

hades
04-22-2023, 08:46 AM
I was about to ask how in the world are you getting that to work with traditionally lubed bullets and then saw PC on the last paragraph.


Being relatively new to 9mm casting I've never traditionally lubed any bullets for this caliber because I was already powder coating and just went straight into that. I don't see the issue using the dillon powder funnel for traditional lubed though.

Am I missing something?

Stopsign32v
04-22-2023, 10:03 AM
Being relatively new to 9mm casting I've never traditionally lubed any bullets for this caliber because I was already powder coating and just went straight into that. I don't see the issue using the dillon powder funnel for traditional lubed though.

Am I missing something?

I'm in the same boat. Went straight to PC when I started reloading.

Bigslug
04-22-2023, 01:49 PM
The .38 S&W sizing die is intended to get that case ready to receive a .362" (ish) diameter bullet. For 9mm, you don't need (or necessarily want) to set it so you're traditionally sizing the full length of it. Obviously, you need the decapping pin deep enough to kick your primers, but you don't want to open the case so much that your bullets are falling/pressing too deep into the case before you have a chance to seat and taper-crimp them in place. Some minor independent adjustment of die body and decapping/expander stem heights is needed. Like MMW says, holding your tongue just right is important.:razz:

In my case, there was already a Webley with an accompanying Lee .38 S&W die set on hand to test and confirm the theory, and buying a duplicate set so one sizer could be permanently committed to the 9mm Dillon quick-change tool head was a cheap and easy fix. The Dillon 9mm sizing die was clearly happier with jacketed bullets and we had to wrestle with the common severe leading issue until will figured that out. The other dies in the Dillon set work just fine to finish out the process. Mine is clearly not the only answer. As long as you end up with a seated bullet that isn't swaged down farther than you started with and your case mouth is TC'd to .380", it doesn't really matter how you get there.

You don't NEED granite-hard bullets, but given the initial leading difficulties Pop and I had in the learning curve, we decided to stick with the air-cooled wheelweight+2% zone.

Ia.redneck
04-22-2023, 09:26 PM
I've shot ALOT of lead in the 9mm. Everything from CZ75 (tight chamber & barrel) to Beretta 92 (needs .358-.359).
The two things that helped me the most were switching to the NOE case expanders. Match expander size to the size of boolit you're seating, he makes them in .001 increments.

Set the expander to just let the base of the boolit enter the case straight, like half of the bottom band.

Next use the Hornady seating die. It is a sliding sleeve design and keeps everything straight and true. I load on an RCBS progressive and it runs smooth with those two dies installed.

hades
04-22-2023, 09:33 PM
I've done a fair amount of tumble lubed and lube sized, just not for the 9mm. PC probably takes me longer than running the lube sizer idk. But they're so much nicer and easier to store for me.


What mold do you have? Or looking to get?

Super Sneaky Steve
04-22-2023, 10:37 PM
For soft lead I find using a gas check with PC helps a lot. With both you can use pure soft lead.

Otherwise, depending on your barrel you may have fitment issues with the wider ogive. In that case look for a boolit with a smaller nose.

Like this lee TL design. Load flush to the shoulder.
313266

murf205
04-23-2023, 01:51 PM
Personally, I i’ve never had an issue loading cast in 9 mm. I can’t tell you how many thousands I cast (various different molds ), loaded, shot, out of multiple firearms. I size to 356, have superb accuracy, zero leading, out of multiple firearms, with various different boolets. My alloy is wheel weights, with a little tin added to help fill out. I have completed the NRA pistol marksmanship course all the way up to and including distinguished expert using my 9 mm Ruger SR9 with Cast Boolets. I don’t consider that some outstanding achievement it’s just some thing that I’ve done. After reading a plethora of posts about the problems that some people have loading nine I guess I’m extremely lucky I don’t know. I’m just never found it to be a problem.

You might be lucky and then you might just be using the right gun. I, too was a lot apprehensive when I started the 9mm journey and it was from all the bad press this round gets. Like you, I use an SR9 and this thing will eat anything you can stuff in it, even 150 gr swc boolits traditionally lubed. I bought a 500 rnd box of Magnus 147 gr BB boolits and they are soft but they don't lead in my gun. I use a full snort Blue Dot load and that may be helping to obturate but the crimp I use is just a touch right at the case mouth.
Stopsign, load it and shoot it. You might not have as much of a problem as you think but 'ya gotta' start somewhere.

armoredman
04-23-2023, 05:27 PM
Well I assumed 9mm casting reloading would be pretty straight forward but apparently from my researching it is anything but that!

So before I start I'm wondering what are some of the tricks you guys have come across that make it easier? The main issue I have been reading is of course you size your lead bullets to .357-3

So far in another thread of mine a member stated his eureka moment was when he started using .38 S&W full length sizing die. I have one on the way but last night I started wondering, what will a, we will call it larger full length sizing die do to help this issue? I could understand a larger expanding die helping but what will a full length sizer do?

Then of course I've read people are using the Lee SE1699 expander plug for .38 S&W. In smaller suggestions I also saw 9x18 Makarov suggestions.


Anyways so the stage is for you guys. I'm really hoping to get some knowledge here and enjoy the journey of 9mm casting.
I'm a little lost - I have been using the Lee 4 die carbide set forever, (the name is starting to wear off!), with the Lee 124gr 356 2R Tumble Lube boolit, sized to .356 after powder coating and I don't have any troubles, even loading in my CZ short chambers, loaded to 1.095 COAL. I wouldn't have ever dreamed of using any other sizing die at all. The only difference between cast and jacketed is flaring the case a TOUCH more, that's it. I have used this boolit in this manner in a bunch of different pistols and pistol caliber carbines without issue.

mike_kaleigh
04-23-2023, 07:30 PM
I have had good luck when i switched to noe HTC356-135-RF-AH2 and Lyman Stainless Pro 4-dies (I have a rl1100). Also when I size brass if i get one the pieces of brass is hard to size I immediately chuck it in recycling, I have found out work hardened brass sizes the bullet down. Also I seat the bullet out as far as I can and kiss the rifling.

btw I size to 356, hitek and use ww/pure alloy, and use hornady oneshot when i size bullets (smooth side bullet size harder)

good luck

Huskerguy
04-24-2023, 05:00 PM
One additional item is actual mold.... I have tried most every mold I can for 9mm, and the one that always shows most accurate and repeatable is this one:

Miha designed this one up himself, and while it looks a bit ugly in the hand, its a GREAT performer. wibsite says it's a 135g but they always come in around 140.5g for me with RR.

https://www.mp-molds.com/product/359-135-swc-round-nose-6-cavity-mold/

Lakehouse2012 - I have been looking for the magic bullet for 9mm. I have multiple options and a lot of them for plated bullets, primarily Berry's. Just finished using up all the FMJ's I had laying around. I have an NOE truncated mold 358-124 TC I am starting to work with. It shoots great in my Ruger Carbine but then so does everything I run down the pipe. I have an M&P 147 grain HP that drops heavier than that and working on those loads. The bullet does look at bit odd at first but I am always on the hunt for the most accurate bullets for anything I shoot. For 38/357 I am down to a SAECO 148 WC that shoots great in my model 66 for league and a RCBS 258-150KT. When I find the magic, I stick with it and make a bunch. I think it must also make a difference that I shoot all CZ's in my 9mm and finding the niche is a trick. Now you have me thinking! What powder and OAL are you running? I am a fan of W231 with Titegroup second and have CFE Pistol as well. Thanks in advance

Lakehouse2012
04-24-2023, 05:19 PM
Lakehouse2012 - I have been looking for the magic bullet for 9mm. I have multiple options and a lot of them for plated bullets, primarily Berry's. Just finished using up all the FMJ's I had laying around. I have an NOE truncated mold 358-124 TC I am starting to work with. It shoots great in my Ruger Carbine but then so does everything I run down the pipe. I have an M&P 147 grain HP that drops heavier than that and working on those loads. The bullet does look at bit odd at first but I am always on the hunt for the most accurate bullets for anything I shoot. For 38/357 I am down to a SAECO 148 WC that shoots great in my model 66 for league and a RCBS 258-150KT. When I find the magic, I stick with it and make a bunch. I think it must also make a difference that I shoot all CZ's in my 9mm and finding the niche is a trick. Now you have me thinking! What powder and OAL are you running? I am a fan of W231 with Titegroup second and have CFE Pistol as well. Thanks in advanceYou wouldn't be disappointed...

I have been running cfe pistol (8lber) for the last few years, it's a consistent but smokey. 3.6g put be safely into 125 power factor, usually 130-132 PF. 930FPS is my goal.

Sent from my SM-A526U using Tapatalk

dearslayer
04-24-2023, 05:54 PM
Following this thread closely as I'm having an issue with my Lee expander not creating enough flair for my cast 9mm . It does create a flare but when I seat them sometimes it does scrape the powder coat and it gathers along the edge of the case. I think mostly because it doesn't sit straight enough at the beginning of the seating process. I have the adjustment as much as possible but it's still not enough. I tried to find the Lee 38S&W powder through expanding plug here in Canada but no luck with it in stock. Ordering from Lee in the US will cost me $20.00 USD plus the price of the plug. Converted in CDN funds it will be about $30 to get the $3.00 plug to my door. I will continue my search.

gwpercle
04-24-2023, 07:25 PM
Following this thread closely as I'm having an issue with my Lee expander not creating enough flair for my cast 9mm . It does create a flare but when I seat them sometimes it does scrape the powder coat and it gathers along the edge of the case. I think mostly because it doesn't sit straight enough at the beginning of the seating process. I have the adjustment as much as possible but it's still not enough. I tried to find the Lee 38S&W powder through expanding plug here in Canada but no luck with it in stock. Ordering from Lee in the US will cost me $20.00 USD plus the price of the plug. Converted in CDN funds it will be about $30 to get the $3.00 plug to my door. I will continue my search.

Get a NOE Expander Plug ... of the proper size ! Tell them your boolit size and they will advise as to correct expander size .

NOE Boolit Mould 358-124-TC (Truncated Cone)- GC (Gas Check) ... the secrete is the gas check... it helps protect the boolit base during seating and you can cast them of a softish alloy and shoot them over 1000 fps with no leading .
I know we all are supposed to hate gas checks but with the 9mm Luger it helps a lot !
Gary

Willie T
04-24-2023, 09:28 PM
I cast and load two bullets for 9mm. Lee 125 round nose and a gas checked NOE truncated cone. I size to .357. Both shoot good. The NOE does not require as much attention to detail and is the more accurate of the two. The Lee is a longer bearing surface and without the gas check it requires more attention to details setting up to load. If you are concerned about 9mm issues you have read about, go back to basics. Take the barrel off your pistol. Make a dummy round and load one long. Taper crimp the case mouth to .381 O.D. (SAAMI) so you know it will fit. Color the projectile with a magic marker. Push it in the chamber and take it out. It will have marks from the lands in the magic marker. Seat a few thousands deeper, color and repeat until it will chamber freely without touching the lands. Measure OAL. Subtract .010-.020 or whatever distance you desire for jump to the lands. Write that down. This is your max OAL. Pull the bullet. Resize and expand the case. Seat a new bullet to your OAL. No taper crimp. Pull the bullet and measure diameter again. If it is smaller, screw the expander in a bit more. Repeat till you can seat and pull the the bullet without swaging down the diameter or scraping off your P.C. Measure the I.D. Of the case. Write that down. This is your minimum case mouth expansion. With a sized and expanded case, seat a new bullet. Gradually screw the taper crimp die down till it will plunk. Measure the case mouth diameter that plunks and write it down. Pull the bullet. Measure diameter to see if the bullet swaged down smaller. If bullet diameter is still what you seated, you are good to go. If it swaged down, measure the case wall thickness at the mouth. Double the case wall thickness and subtract from the cartridge mouth diameter that plunked. That will give you the bullet diameter that will chamber in that case. Use this to adjust where you have room to adjust. If it is just .001 you may be able to size the bullet .001 smaller. If it is more you may need to use cases with thinner walls. It is a little work on the front side but it will eliminate any issues before you have any issues.
Willie

MT Gianni
04-25-2023, 12:04 AM
https://castboolits.gunloads.com/showthread.php?121737-Setting-up-for-boolits-in-a-new-9mm

Petander
04-25-2023, 07:21 AM
What Lakehouse said above works for me too.

I used to shoot heavy (158) subsonic cast in suppressed carbines. I went through all those large expander and alloy and mold "tricks" etc.

Now I use a Mihec 135 bevel base NLG mold to get standard 9mm ammo. I PC and size .357. And load with the little Dillon Square Deal press, all standard. No tricks. Everything is easy and shoots clean and nice.

Soundguy
04-25-2023, 07:51 AM
Lee makes a universal expander too...

JonB_in_Glencoe
04-25-2023, 08:27 AM
I had a custom insert made for my Lee 9mm Powder-thru expander die.
It's not as fat as the 38 S&W, but it's longer than the 9mm insert ...something I found is just as important.
I use boolits sized to .357

bedbugbilly
04-25-2023, 09:21 AM
A cartridge gauge for the 9mm is a handy thing to have on your bench to check your loaded rounds.

And don't forget to load a few dummy rounds and do a plunk test on your individual pistol - cycle the dummy rounds to make sure they cycle as well.

I also changed my expanding plug out like so many others. I have used 120ish grain truncated style and 120ish grain RN Ideal/Lyman 358-242 - sized to .356 and tumble lubed - never had a leading issue - knock on wood.

Will note my experience but may not apply to others. My first 9mm was a Ruger SR9 - a great pistol IMHO. It shot and cycled a 120is grain truncated or RB over 3.5 gr of Bullseye very well. When I got my S & W Shield, it wouldn't cycle with 3.5 gr of BE, but did very well with 3.7 gr of BE - so I changed my loading to 3.7 gr of BE for both the SR9 % Shield and it worked very well out of both pistols. I added a Glock 26 and the same load works well out if it as well. My point in mentioning this is that if you are loading for more than one pistol - when you work up your loads, don't assume the same loading will cycle well in each pistol.

Good luck and enjoy!

Soundguy
04-25-2023, 09:37 AM
Agreed on the cartridge test blocks. I have the Lyman one that does ? 6 different cartridges
Nice easy check for drop in/ drop out..and you know you are good.

dearslayer
04-25-2023, 01:20 PM
Get a NOE Expander Plug ... of the proper size ! Tell them your boolit size and they will advise as to correct expander size .

NOE Boolit Mould 358-124-TC (Truncated Cone)- GC (Gas Check) ... the secrete is the gas check... it helps protect the boolit base during seating and you can cast them of a softish alloy and shoot them over 1000 fps with no leading .
I know we all are supposed to hate gas checks but with the 9mm Luger it helps a lot !
Gary

Well I did reach out to NOE this morning and they did reply with a suggestion. Unfortunately given the fact that I live in Canada it seems that ordering the proper expander plug for $24 US dollars and having it shipped to me which would cost another $48 US dollars would make it almost cost prohibitive. I'm talking close to maybe $80 or more Canadian to have it sent to my door. I'm not aware of any Canadian dealers for NOE. $40 I think I'll pass and try to come up with another solution.

pworley1
04-25-2023, 01:28 PM
While there are a few tricks, 9mm isnt that difficult.

Items that work for me...: (NOTE- I am a USPSA and Steel Challenge competitor, so I have a favorite mold that I have stuffed probably +20,000 into cases)

1) Sizing projectiles at .357
2) Bevel Base mold, whether you are PC or Hitek coat, its a fairly delicate material loading into the case. BB is a huge advantage to start the process.
3) minimum bell mouthing, almost non-existent flaring of the case mouth.
4) I use a standard 9mm resize/deprime die in a progressive press. When you get around to putting projectile in, you will see case bulge. All testing I've done over the years, when I pull projectiles, they are staying at .357.
5) my lead isnt all that hard, usually 12-13brn. Typically I use range recovery and naturally is comes in around there.

Case bulge isnt an issue. While it may not look pretty, but is not affecting the shot. Keeping the interface tight is more important to me then looks. Going the other direction- with a larger sized brass and a looser connection risks gas bypass and inconsistent pressures and velocity.

Hope this helps,

Everything he said except I use this mold LEE 6 Cavity Bullet Mold 90457 356-125-2R and size .358 after powder coating.

Soundguy
04-25-2023, 01:42 PM
Sounds like a tapered center punch may be the cheap method..

Assnolax
04-25-2023, 01:49 PM
The only hiccup i had on 9mm cast boolits was was the stock dillon expander was shaving lead. Swapped to the photoescapeinc pdu/mr bullet feeder powder die. been gravy ever since.

higgins
04-25-2023, 04:40 PM
I have pulled many PC bullets from 9mm cartridges picked up at the range. I'd estimate 50% of them have the PC scraped off to some extent so be sure to expand enough to avoid that when seating. I'll bet most of the people who loaded these scraped bullets had no idea they were doing it.

dearslayer
04-25-2023, 04:55 PM
I have pulled many PC bullets from 9mm cartridges picked up at the range. I'd estimate 50% of them have the PC scraped off to some extent so be sure to expand enough to avoid that when seating. I'll bet most of the people who loaded these scraped bullets had no idea they were doing it.
The problem I'm having is the fact that I can't expand it anymore. The bullets sit on top of the flare but unbalanced and I think when I'm seating they are not going in straight because they are not balanced on the flare. I think they're being seated at a bit of an angle resulting in the case scraping the powder coat off the boolit. I don't have any more adjustment left so I have to change something.

dondiego
04-25-2023, 05:09 PM
I have never encountered a flare die that wouldn't way over expand a case. What equipment are you using?

Willie T
04-25-2023, 05:22 PM
A seating stem that fits your bullet might remedy that.

dearslayer
04-25-2023, 06:36 PM
I have never encountered a flare die that wouldn't way over expand a case. What equipment are you using?

I'm using a Lee classic turret 4 hole press. I'm going to have to take things apart maybe clean things up see if there's something on usual going on. I would think that I should be able to over expand if anything at the very least. I'm also using Lee precision dies including the factory crimp.

dondiego
04-25-2023, 06:49 PM
I'm using a Lee classic turret 4 hole press. I'm going to have to take things apart maybe clean things up see if there's something on usual going on. I would think that I should be able to over expand if anything at the very least. I'm also using Lee precision dies including the factory crimp.

I have over expanded a few cases using a LEE 4 die set. Check it out!

Assnolax
04-26-2023, 12:41 PM
Ive had bad luck with cast and the lee factory crimp causing leading. Pull a loaded bullet after and see if it is swaging the lead down. With cast bullets i just remove the flare and call it done.

Super Sneaky Steve
04-26-2023, 04:24 PM
Following this thread closely as I'm having an issue with my Lee expander not creating enough flair for my cast 9mm . It does create a flare but when I seat them sometimes it does scrape the powder coat and it gathers along the edge of the case. I think mostly because it doesn't sit straight enough at the beginning of the seating process. I have the adjustment as much as possible but it's still not enough. I tried to find the Lee 38S&W powder through expanding plug here in Canada but no luck with it in stock. Ordering from Lee in the US will cost me $20.00 USD plus the price of the plug. Converted in CDN funds it will be about $30 to get the $3.00 plug to my door. I will continue my search.

Some lee seater dies have a carbide ring and will remove the case flare before the bullet is seated. I don't have this problem with my 9mm dies but I did on my 45 auto. I switched seating dies to a Hornady and no more scraping the sides. Try fitting a flared case into your seater die by and and see if it touches the sides as it goes in.

fredj338
04-26-2023, 05:22 PM
I keep reading about how hard the 9mm is with cast bullets but I just dont have any issues. All my 9mm are pretty new, my BHP form the late 70s is the oldest. I have no issues running medium to hard cast 124-147 with good to exc accuracy measured at 25y from a bench. I played with sizes from 0.356-0.358 & settled on 0.357 for everything. Most of my shooting is IDPA or self defense training/practice but getting good hits at 40y isnt hard. I have switched to PC for the last 4-5y though. I also use a MBF funnel in my Dillon die for expanding. I also shun the LFCD, I use an old set of RCBS on my Dillon

Forrest r
04-27-2023, 07:33 AM
I have over expanded a few cases using a LEE 4 die set. Check it out!

The issue with lee dies isn't if they can "over expand". What the lee dies actually do is "over flare" the case mouth.

A lyman m-die that has a step/lip at the top of the expander button. The m-die expands deep into the case expanding the case enough so that the base of the bullet doesn't get swaged down.
https://i.imgur.com/vnmkz9e.jpg

A m-die next to a lee expander. You can clearly see the high water mark/ring left by the mouth of the case on the lee expander. The m-die goes +/- 100% deeper expanding the case twice as deep protecting the bullets base.
https://i.imgur.com/AtiYtlr.jpg

A factory lee expander next to a custom home-made expander for the 9mm.
https://i.imgur.com/aFsP8TI.jpg

When using the extremely short factory lee expanders, rock hard/extremely hard alloy's when casting are a huge plus.

Myself, I usually cast my 9mm bullets with a 8/9bhn alloy and use +/- 25,000psi loads. I use that custom expander pictured above and a lee die set to reload my 9mm's.
https://i.imgur.com/V87WlTN.jpg