PDA

View Full Version : Bullet contacting rifeling



Midohhntr
02-04-2022, 07:57 AM
Testing some new boolits from the Noe 460-315 and noticed they were a little snug when chambering in my Marlin 1895. Don't know if it can be seen well but they engage the rifleing a bit. Sized to .459 after pc... Are these still ok to shoot this way? I could use the Hornady brass I have as it's shorter.

greenjoytj
02-04-2022, 08:24 AM
I suppose you could trim back the cartridge cases just a few thou to eliminate contact with the rifling.
Sizing after powder coating corrects the bullet diameter but doesn’t address the thick powder coat on the bullet ogive. Shortening the cartridge cases a bit will keep the ogive further from the rifling. The slightly shorter cases shouldn’t be an issue unless you are trying for maximum loads of black powder. With smokeless the slightly shorter case might benefit the load by removing a tiny bit of unused case volume.

RickinTN
02-04-2022, 09:01 AM
You probably have a great situation for accuracy. As long as when you de-chamber a round the throat doesn't try to pull the bullet out of the case.
Good Luck!
Rick

Grayone
02-04-2022, 09:15 AM
Testing some new boolits from the Noe 460-315 and noticed they were a little snug when chambering in my Marlin 1895. Don't know if it can be seen well but they engage the rifleing a bit. Sized to .459 after pc... Are these still ok to shoot this way? I could use the Hornady brass I have as it's shorter.

Actually that is desired with a cast boolit for accuracy as long as it will extract without leaving a boolit in the throat. If you are worried about pressure a cast lead boolit will have much less pressure than a similar weight jacketed bullet with comparable powder charge weights.

mehavey
02-04-2022, 09:21 AM
as long as when you de-chamber a round the throat doesn't try to pull the bullet out of the case
^ ^ ^ ^ this ^ ^ ^ ^
:2_high5:

Midohhntr
02-04-2022, 09:34 AM
I couldn't close the action on my Handi-rifle at all, with the Marlin they extracted ok

badguybuster
02-04-2022, 09:51 AM
You could also use the Hornady Leverevolution brass. Its a smidge shorter than standard

mdi
02-04-2022, 12:47 PM
Not familiar with that bullet and can't tell from the pic, but, can you seat the bullet any deeper? Crimp groove?

tmanbuckhunter
02-04-2022, 01:11 PM
As stated, as long as it's not trying to pull the bullet out upon extracting, it's fine. It's actually ideal.

Midohhntr
02-04-2022, 01:35 PM
Not familiar with that bullet and can't tell from the pic, but, can you seat the bullet any deeper? Crimp groove?
It’s crimped in the groove as shone..not a very deep one but it’s there.

Midohhntr
02-04-2022, 01:37 PM
As stated, as long as it's not trying to pull the bullet out upon extracting, it's fine. It's actually ideal.

I’ll go with it. I’ll use the shorter Hornaday brass for the Handi-rifle

gwpercle
02-04-2022, 01:48 PM
You probably have a great situation for accuracy. As long as when you de-chamber a round the throat doesn't try to pull the bullet out of the case.
Good Luck!
Rick

De-chamber is the new term for extract a round ?
I try to keep up with the changing terminology ...it ain't easy !
Gary

RickinTN
02-04-2022, 03:28 PM
The Handy rifle is a single shot. Just seat the bullet a bit deeper until the action will close. Ignore the crimp groove.
Rick

Winger Ed.
02-04-2022, 05:13 PM
There are articles in different loading books that say your best accuracy, and with no big spike in chamber pressure
is attained when a Lead boolit just barely touches the rifling enough to engrave/leave small marks like yours show.

I've found this to be true with my rifles.

sigep1764
02-04-2022, 09:15 PM
Id seat the boolit a little deeper in the case if I could. I had some rounds for my 30-30 that were a little hard to close the lever on. It didn't give a warm feeling about what it could do to the action. My 2 cents.

Rcmaveric
02-05-2022, 01:27 AM
I normally disregard crimp grooves and crimp where it sits.

I do however measure my bullet seating depth. I dont recommend ball seating (ie seating a bullet into the leade or riffling). Maybe if the load is tunned for it but. Once upon a time i tried ball seating. The extra recoil was enough for to suspicious. Quickloads and some heavy Google foo lead me to figure it out.

In a nut shell seating into lands spikes your initial start presssure and all things powder burn wise that snow balls into. Plus pressure spikes affect accuracy.

I seat .004 off the lands and udjust deeper if needed for feeding reliability. This gives me lee way for minor inconsistencies from seating depth that would affect chambering.

In my riffles and hand guns, I have noticed increased accuracy and higher obtainable velocities from not breach seating.

The arguments for breaching seating is the bullet is aligned and supported during firing for better accuracy. I found high pressures and lower velocites but with usable accuracy. For seating .004 the argument is increased reliable chambering from negligible seating depth variances, increased accuracy because of gentler start pressurszes which allows loading to high velocities.

I will say i have seen people do amazing ball seating but it didnt work for me. Try it all ways and see what your guns and experince is.

Sent from my SM-G991U using Tapatalk