PDA

View Full Version : Do you use something like Frankford Arsenols Drop out spray? Yay? Nay? Opinions?



blasternank
01-01-2021, 08:44 PM
I smoked my molds and a guy I know said I was doing it old school. He said he uses Frankford Arsenols Drop Out spray on his molds. What is your opinions on that? I've heard many say never use anything that you spray into a mold. Pro's? Cons? Opinions?

Thanks!

RickinTN
01-01-2021, 08:51 PM
If you get the mold hot enough and the melt hot enough you shouldn't have to use anything. Bullets should just drop out.
Good Luck,
Rick

DAFzipper
01-01-2021, 09:00 PM
Shouldn't be necessary. Will reduce the diameter. Better off polishing if it's sticking. Check edges of cavities for any burrs. To polish leave sprew plate open. Set a nut on top and fill cavity. Use fine lapping compound on bullet. Gently close the mould and turn bullet with wrench on the nut.

Sent from my SM-T713 using Tapatalk

Finster101
01-01-2021, 09:05 PM
Like the others I have never had to smoke a mold or use a release agent. Adjusting the temp. and finding what the mold likes is a big factor. I jot down the temp I get the best result at in a log book and it has been a big help. I tend to cast a lot of boolits of the same type at one time rather than small batches.

Mk42gunner
01-01-2021, 09:16 PM
What the others have said.

I don't even like smoking a mold, except as a last resort.

Robert

44Blam
01-02-2021, 12:55 AM
I smoke my molds but I did use that stuff once and I would recommend against it. It's unnecessary and it is hard to remove.

Beagle333
01-02-2021, 01:52 AM
Use a mold oven. Learn the temp each one likes and you'll never need anything to help them drop out. I've never used smoke or anything else.

Bazoo
01-02-2021, 02:27 AM
I don't use none of that stuff. If a mould won't drop easy, it needs to be lapped or otherwise have a burr removed.

Bent Ramrod
01-02-2021, 09:15 AM
I’ve used a couple of cans. It works OK, properly applied, but no better than the smoke from the candles I use for fluxing the melt.

It does seem to be harder to remove from the mould than candle soot. Whether this is good or bad depends on whether you want to have it stay on the mould through several casting sessions or whether you want to clean everything off and start over (or not).

I suppose that you could “reduce the diameter of your boolit” if you held the nozzle an inch away from the mould face and sprayed for a minute or so, but properly applied, I’ve never seen any diameter reduction.

I’ve bought most of my oversized accumulation of moulds used at gun shows, and “cranky” doesn’t begin to describe some of them. Some are truly the dregs of mould society. “They need our Help!” :mrgreen:

Cosmic_Charlie
01-02-2021, 11:27 AM
I don't use anything now. Used to smoke the cavities but I stopped doing that too. I have aluminum, brass and 1 steel mold and they all drop the boolits nicely. When the mold gets too hot is when the boolits won't fall out. I run my pot at 700 deg. and will take a break when I need to let the molds cool. I use plenty of tin in my alloys and I think that helps too.

Burnt Fingers
01-02-2021, 12:27 PM
I have used a light coating on a couple of stubborn sinker/lure molds.

I would never use it on a bullet mold.

I have smoked a few molds. It's amazing what a difference a light smoke on the mold can make.

I know people say get the mold hot and get the melt hot.....yeah, when the boolits still are filling out or are covered in wrinkles a light smoke stops ALL that.

I've rarely had to smoke a iron mold, once in a while a brass mold, but aluminum? I've smoked almost every one. I haven't cast as many boolits as many people here, only around 35k last year, all for personal use, but I've found that the smoke from a butane lighter can make a BIG difference on a aluminum mold.

mdi
01-02-2021, 12:39 PM
Like many others I tried a bunch of different "release agents" in my molds early in my casting. Today, nothing goes in my molds except lead...

flyingmonkey35
01-02-2021, 01:30 PM
The frankford arsenal release spray is just arosaled powderd graphite.

You can clean it right off with break clean.

Apply to a cold mold.

I use it on my lee molds.




Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

ShooterAZ
01-02-2021, 02:07 PM
It can potentially reduce your boolit diameter. I will sometimes use it on sticky ingot molds, but not on boolit molds. I still have a half a can of it from when I first started casting years ago. It's best to learn how to regulate your alloy and mold temperatures so that it won't be needed.

Idz
01-02-2021, 02:21 PM
Its supposed to be applied as a thin atomic layer like careful smoking not used as spray paint. If properly applied I doubt there is anybody on this forum who could measure the difference in bullet diameter. New clean aluminum molds sometimes have sticky spots that the release agent cures.

ShooterAZ
01-02-2021, 02:26 PM
Good point, and I'll also add that more is NOT better in this instance! I will occasionally smoke a pesky mold, but after trying the spray I won't use it on any of my molds again.

mdi
01-02-2021, 02:51 PM
Dunno about bullet diameter, but the spray is actually a contaminate and leaves a dull finish on the bullets...

I guess if one feels the need, it's OK, but I have about 12 Lee molds, and 3 or 4 Lyman molds and don't use anything in the cavities. Perhaps my "seasoning" has something to do with no need. I clean a new mold thoroughly, heat it on my hot plate to very hot, and allow to cool. I repeat this 3 or 4 times, then preheat the mold and start casting...

Rcmaveric
01-02-2021, 03:23 PM
I have personally never used. I do occasionally smoke a mold while breaking in a new mold. You would think 900*F lead would cook the oils out of a mold block. But sometimes the oil is stubborn and the bullets are sticky. I swear smoking a mold is magical, speeds up burning off any oils and helps those pesky bullets to drop till the mold is "seasoned" well enough to drop bullets easily.

I dont know how many bullets it takes to seasoned a Lee mold but a rough guess is 40 pounds. After that bullets seam to leap from all my molds.

After that I just store the molds properly.

This actually comes often and the sage advice is always to never spray anything on the mold.

Sent from my SM-N970U using Tapatalk

heebs
01-02-2021, 03:53 PM
The only use I have for it is on the lip of my shotmaker. Works great for that.

John Boy
01-02-2021, 04:08 PM
All my molds cast with naked cavities except pins are lubed with paraffin

Conditor22
01-02-2021, 04:12 PM
make sure the mold is 110% clean
make sure there are no burs on the cavities
preheat mold
have alloy at good casting temperature 680-720° (750° for pure)
purge spout before each pour to remove cooler lead and you should be golden

I have been known to lightly smoke a stubborn mold or burn out a cavity with a propane torch.

I've bought molds with SO MUCH SMOKE ON THEM THE SIDES DIDN'T CLOSE :holysheep


BTW any variance in pot temperature or mold temperature can affect the size/weight of the boolit, that's why "OCD" casters monitor the temperature of their molds as well as the pot.

charlie b
01-02-2021, 04:15 PM
I used to smoke molds all the time. Now days I don't use it at all, even on my Lee molds. Just clean and use.

I just got a few new Lee molds. Cleaned really well with acetone. Each one only took about 20 casts to 'break in'. My lead pot usually runs 600F.

gwpercle
01-02-2021, 10:02 PM
I smoked my molds and a guy I know said I was doing it old school. He said he uses Frankford Arsenols Drop Out spray on his molds. What is your opinions on that? I've heard many say never use anything that you spray into a mold. Pro's? Cons? Opinions?

Thanks!

The only drawback I have found is the coating will / can build up over time . At one time I used it every session ... but the build up started causing problems and cleaning all that black crud of every mould was Royal Pane in the behind . Stopped using it . Found a spray of dry lube , the kind with micro-teflon in it worked better and didn't leave a build up on the mould .
The Drop Out is good to spray the inside wall of your casting pot and to spay on your casting ladle, inside and out or ingot moulds ...
After a mould is seasoned and broken in they should require nothing ...but if having trouble use Dry Lube Spray...it doesn't contanminate or build up and any excess spray wipes off .
Gary

Gtrubicon
01-02-2021, 10:30 PM
I’ve never needed a product like this, hope I dont

Jack Stanley
01-03-2021, 09:41 PM
The only product I've used recently is smoke from a match or the old time NEI "Mold Prep".

Jack

slim1836
01-03-2021, 10:35 PM
I used a mold release agent and smoked them, hopefully never again. YMMV is all I'm saying.

Slim

LenH
01-04-2021, 11:12 AM
The only thing that I use what is left of that mold release spray is to coat the pins for a stubborn HP pins. I ruined an old Lee with that stuff.

fredj338
01-04-2021, 02:48 PM
I dont use anything on my molds, not even smoking them. Some require more break in than others but all release, iron or alum.

TNsailorman
01-04-2021, 04:18 PM
I first tried using mold release agents(2 or 3 different brands), they caused more problems than they cured. Then I tried the smoke coating method. That was better than mold release but it still caused some stickiness. I finally quit using anything but a dry mold and that worked better for me than anything I had tried. I usually cast in small batches and cleaned my mold well between batches and that worked out for me. my experience anyway and may not work for all, james

Cherokee
01-06-2021, 01:41 PM
I have never in 50+ years used any mold cavity "drop out' stuff. I have polished a few, it works.

Vegas Vince
01-06-2021, 02:18 PM
50 years of smoking molds, always works. After several years if they start sticking, clean them well & re-smoke.

fcvan
01-06-2021, 08:27 PM
When I first started casting on my own, I bought Lee and smoked with Ohio Tip matches. I don't recall ever seeing Dad do anything but cast with his Saeco molds, bought when Saeco was just down the road 20 miles. He cast until they were good, never did anything other than that. I have his old molds, he is still with us, he just leaves his casting/loading to his sons.

I thought Aluminum might be different so I smoked. 35+ years later, I just wash with Dawn and hot water and an old toothbrush. I have bought many molds since, the only problem with boolits sticking has been burrs. I use chopsticks for mold maintenance, small end for lubing with 2 cycle oil, large end for cleaning/de-burring and such. I have one Lee mold I know I have cast 750K boolits with, rebuilt 3 times. By rebuilt I mean tapping and replacing the sprue plate bolt with a slightly larger bolt due to wear.

Current sprue bolt has been good for the last 500K. First rebuild was due to loaning the mold to a noob who almost wrecked it. He did offer to replace the 2 molds he messed up. I fixed both by removing the sprue plate, lapping the mold tops, and re-tapping the bolt. Maintaining the both tension has negated the need for further repair.

Using wooden chopsticks has been critical to good casting. I dip the tip with 2 cycle oil and the wood fibers hold an ample amount of oil. I lube the mating surfaces, and lightly swab the sprue plate on only one side, the cutting side. Yes, I have gotten oil in the cavities, took 30 or 40 castings to purge the oil, I just resorted to hot soapy water.

I have had several new molds, NOE and Lee that just cast and dropped out of the box. Part of that may have been due to good temp of the melt, but I generally wash my molds before first use. I haven't smoked a mold in 30 years but have washed a bunch. BTW, I still have Saeco and Lyman molds, always stored with cast in them. The outside of the molds got patina rust, due to the Pacific North West climate, but the cavities are pristine. Never a problem in CO, very dry climate.

El Greco
01-06-2021, 09:09 PM
I smoked my molds and a guy I know said I was doing it old school. He said he uses Frankford Arsenols Drop Out spray on his molds. What is your opinions on that? I've heard many say never use anything that you spray into a mold. Pro's? Cons? Opinions?

Thanks!
Don’t do it. It makes your boolits smaller and your mounds dirty.

45workhorse
01-06-2021, 09:34 PM
I have sprayed the top of my lead pot, helps keep rust down! Never in the molds/moulds!

oldsalt444
01-06-2021, 09:49 PM
The frankford arsenal release spray is just arosaled powderd graphite.

You can clean it right off with break clean.

Apply to a cold mold.

I use it on my lee molds.




Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

Lee specifically says to NOT use any spray-on mold release. Just a little too much can block the vent cuts. I use a wooden match to smoke the mold. Leaves a very light coating of smoke which is just right.

45DUDE
01-06-2021, 09:52 PM
When I have one stick I take my screwdriver that I put a 90 on the end and a sharp end like an ice pick and when one is a little sticky poke it the middle of the boolit from the top and it falls out easy. Some times a hammer handle works ok. Lyman molds seem to be the worst to stick <THEY DON'T STICK-THEY FIT TIGHT> but when you get the routine down it's easy. Molds that stick a little make very good boolits. The more you use them the better they fall. I hate to smooth a good mold that sticks a little because you can't undo it.

NorthMoccasin
01-08-2021, 08:04 PM
I have used the FA spray on balky aluminum molds without problems and good results. The key is DONT USE TOO MUCH! and wipe the cavities with a clean Q tip to remove all but a very thin film. Also wipe the block faces with a Q tip. If you worry about the vent lines use a tooth brush to clean them out. This technique has turned stubborn molds into easy droppers. Not every mold needs it but it sure helps some.