PDA

View Full Version : Let's revisit some of those home made case lubes..........



3006guns
05-12-2020, 06:52 AM
Always looking for ways to avoid spending money, I finally decided on a home made case lube............a mixture of castor oil and denatured alcohol in a spray bottle. I've been using it for well over a year and it performs quite well, but has the same problem as a lot of other home brew formulas................how in the dickens do you remove it after sizing? You can't leave it on the cases, so it has to go.

I've used hot water, hot water and soap, hand cleaning with a rag, etc........all of which kind of negates the "advantages" of a do it yourself lube. Cleaning in alcohol would probably be best, but that's pretty expensive. You could pitch the cases in the tumbler I guess, but all that does is foul the media eventually.

Another solution I found was dissolving Lee case lube in a small tub of water, then swirling the cases through it and allowing them to dry. It works well, distributing lube all over the cases and ordinary handling during the reloading process removes it. The only disadvantage: waiting for those cases to dry, usually overnight.

Are the lanolin based case lubes easier to remove? Since most of those recipies call for alcohol also, it sounds like the same problem.

smithnframe
05-12-2020, 07:12 AM
Try tumbling them!

AnthonyB
05-12-2020, 07:20 AM
Liquid lanolin plus Heet gasoline treatment from a spray bottle works for me for all but case necks. The spray would work if I stood cases up to spray them. I de-prime, clean, lube and size, then clean again. Stainless pins and water are your friend here - no media to foul.
Tony

MOA
05-12-2020, 07:30 AM
As AnthonyB said. Stainless pins and water are your friend here - no media to foul.

3006guns
05-12-2020, 10:20 AM
Hmmm.............stainless pins and tumbler. Good idea! I haven't treated myself to new gear in quite awhile!

Slugster
05-12-2020, 11:53 AM
I use lacquer thinner as my all purpose shop solvent. And yes I know the dangers inherent with using L.T. Only used outside and once drained off, whatever I have cleaned stays outside until all vapors/odors are gone. Acetone works in a pinch.

bangerjim
05-12-2020, 06:00 PM
Lacquer thinner IS mainly acetone with other VOC's added to it to adjust the drying time of nitrocellulose lacquers. Each maker has their own specific mixture of acetone and the other "stuff" to formulate their specific brand. That is why some brands are better than others. And smell different. I use only pure acetone in my shop for cleaning. Every brand of pure acetone is consistent and works the same. And I use lacquer thinner for ONLY thinning spraying and/or brushing lacquers.

As far as case lubes I just buy the little white tub of Unique Case Lube. I generally have to buy a new one very 5-6 years! The stuff goes a l-o-n-g way and wipes off easily with just a rag. And costs so very little, much more time-efficient that wasting time trying to mix up some witch's brew lube.

banger

WRideout
05-12-2020, 07:46 PM
From my limited research, it looks like HEET gas line antifreeze is basically methanol. Probably most of the other brands are too. If you only need small quantities, that may be the way to go.

Wayne

Stewbaby
05-12-2020, 11:31 PM
Red heet, too much water in the yellow. 1:12 or so

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20200513/b1a023630cae9585cfd3203ff760d3cf.jpg

EDG
05-13-2020, 12:31 AM
Most people will waste more money experimenting than a 10 year suppcosts.a good lube costs.

BigAlofPa.
05-13-2020, 02:55 AM
I use olive oil. I put some on the lube pad and rub it in. A treatment last a long time.

toallmy
05-13-2020, 07:41 AM
I use a recipe or two from a member that passed recently . The first is a mixture of lanolin and Vaseline that I apply to a pad to lube bottle necked brass before full length sizing . The second is a mixture of lanolin and Heet the red jug as posted above to mix up a spray lube used to lube strait walled brass .
I try to prepare brass in advance to be loaded - by depriming & resizing it - then a quick bath in citrus acid + hot water to remove the case lube - then a short run through the vibrating tumbler with NU-Finish added to the media .
Since I started using lizard bedding media I haven't had a problem with plugged primer pocket flash holes .
I put together this process with information from members here at Cast Boolits and am quite happy with the results .

Froogal
05-13-2020, 10:13 AM
I just use the LEE case sizing lube. Mix 50/50 with water and it goes a L O N G way. Apply to the cases, let it dry, then size and deprime, and then into the walnut shell media. ALL of the lube comes off and the brass is clean and shiny.

bangerjim
05-13-2020, 01:59 PM
From my limited research, it looks like HEET gas line antifreeze is basically methanol. Probably most of the other brands are too. If you only need small quantities, that may be the way to go.

Wayne

Just buy REAL methanol in the paint department of Lowe's or Home Despot. 100% alcohol. Get in either quarts or gallons. I buy all my shop solvents a gallon at at time.....saves money.

flyingmonkey35
05-13-2020, 02:11 PM
Honestly I go back to hornady case lube (the paste) over my homemade lanion / 99% alcohol mixture.

I find both work very well. But for bigger cases I find the other stuff just works.



Sent from my SM-G960U using Tapatalk

Elmer Fudd
05-13-2020, 02:32 PM
I use 91% rubbing alcohol and lanolin. A scoop or a big drool of lanolin with enough alcohol to dissolve it in a pump bottle. This is my "cheap" version of Dillon's Case Lube.

I use Imperial Sizing Wax for forming a lot of cases, and Ballistol for more and more sizing chores. The lanolin can build up in dies. Ditto Imperial. I haven't seen Ballistol do that yet.

Dapaki
05-13-2020, 03:31 PM
I too use 91% rubbing alcohol and lanolin, a 4oz bottle on lanolin into a 32oz bottle of 91%. Cheap, easy to remove, wipes off with a clean rag, hands get some on them, just rub it in.

John Boy
05-13-2020, 04:24 PM
Buy a can of Bag Balm for 9 bucks ,a light finger swipe is all that is needed and the unused left over container can be willed to your grandchildren:
https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0108/4823/9675/products/bb_original_8oz_1_370x.jpg?v=1551563373

longrange2
05-13-2020, 10:30 PM
some petrol neat to wash cases your done

sureYnot
05-13-2020, 10:56 PM
Red heet, too much water in the yellow. 1:12 or so

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20200513/b1a023630cae9585cfd3203ff760d3cf.jpgThis and I fill a gallon ziplock about half full of brass. Couple squirts. Tumble a little. Couple more squirts and tumble thoroughly (10-20 seconds). Seems to always get enough inside enough of them too, even with the bottle necks.

Sent from my XT1710-02 using Tapatalk

Zingger
05-14-2020, 09:48 AM
John Boy beat me to it! Bag balm works wonders. I learned this to my frustrations with the 444 marlin. It was the only lube that wouldn't leave stuck cases for me to deal with. Possibly a bad die, but I have never, Never had that many issues with a cartridge. I have used a few different including the Hornady wipe on as well as the Royal Case and Die lube. RCBS stuff too. I still prefer the BB over them all.

Mytmousemalibu
05-14-2020, 10:09 AM
I use Dillon DCL (now made myself) which is lanolin mixed in isopropyl alcohol.

I put a good 2-handful scoop of brass into a plastic bag and a couple mists of DCL and couple of straight alcohol. Shake and mix to distribute and dump out. I keep using the same old bag as it collects residual lube that participates with every use. The case mouths tend to scrape up tiny spots of lube that keep the expander ball lubed. The alcohol also "reactivates" dried lube.

I do not bother with removal. The lanolin coat is very thin on the brass but its more than enough to be effective but not enough to be a problem. Sure you can feel it on the completed ammo but its never been a problem so its not worth my time removing it. It doesn't kill primers, doesn't foul the gun, nothing problematic has come up in the 5yrs or so of using this method 20,000rds per year average.

gwpercle
05-17-2020, 12:02 PM
Ordinary case lube - dissolve as much Lee Case Lube in a small glass jar of Denatured Alcohol as it will dissolve , strain into a small spray bottle , use as a spray on case lube .

Really Tough Resizing case lube - STP Oil Treatment ...messy but the best , apply by rolling cases on a clean ink pad that has had STP applied to it . You will have to remove it from the sized case but the stuff works!
Gary

1hole
05-21-2020, 06:10 PM
Always looking for ways to avoid spending money, I finally decided on a home made case lube............a mixture of castor oil and denatured alcohol in a spray bottle. I've been using it for well over a year and it performs quite well, but has the same problem as a lot of other home brew formulas................how in the dickens do you remove it after sizing? You can't leave it on the cases, so it has to go.

I've used hot water, hot water and soap, hand cleaning with a rag, etc........all of which kind of negates the "advantages" of a do it yourself lube. Cleaning in alcohol would probably be best, but that's pretty expensive. You could pitch the cases in the tumbler I guess, but all that does is foul the media eventually.

Another solution I found was dissolving Lee case lube in a small tub of water, then swirling the cases through it and allowing them to dry. It works well, distributing lube all over the cases and ordinary handling during the reloading process removes it. The only disadvantage: waiting for those cases to dry, usually overnight.

Are the lanolin based case lubes easier to remove? Since most of those recipies call for alcohol also, it sounds like the same problem.

Castor oil is stinky and quite slick but, like lanolin and STP, it's nasty stuff to use. There are much cleaner alternatives that really don't need to be removed. Both castor and lanolin ARE oils so water can't do much good for cleaning. If you really want to use either of them wet a cloth or paper towel with mineral spirits/odorless paint thinner (Walmart's paint dept) to cut and wipe off the oil. But, IMHO, it's a PITA to use such oily stuff for sizing.

If you're looking for a spray try Hornady's One Shot; it works fine IF the user bothers to read and follow the instructions but for those who think they don't need no stinking instructions it's not much good. (But that applies to anything that's used incorrectly doesn't it? :) )

(There's a sticky on case lubes on the Reloading Tools forum.)

NyFirefighter357
05-21-2020, 06:34 PM
This is what I use, no need to clean off after either

https://www.homedepot.com/p/Klein-Tools-32-oz-Premium-Synthetic-Clear-Lubricant-51028/100660159

Wayne Smith
05-22-2020, 07:46 AM
I'm in the Bag Balm users group. Have been for years. Not only good for a lube it is also good for your hands.

fguffey
05-26-2020, 12:28 PM
I can not take credit for the No Name case lube. Many years ago I could not understand why there had to be a case lube made for case lubing so a gathered up all the lube I could find and or had available. Everything seemed to work until the going got tough, when it got tuff I eliminated a few of the lubes and started on the next batch. And then finally I found a lube that was slicker than okra, the ability of the brass to resist sizing was eliminated.

I saved all of the case lube by RCBS, Lyman, Dillon ect. for the easy stuff but when the going got tuff I used the no-name stuff. And now that time is running out I am running out of no-name lube.

I have thought it would be nice if I checked the origin and then I thought about it; I believe I would have trouble finding anyone that would appreciate the effort.

F. Guffey

1hole
06-04-2020, 11:45 AM
I can not take credit for the No Name case lube. .... I have thought it would be nice if I checked the origin and then I thought about it; I believe I would have trouble finding anyone that would appreciate the effort.

Guffy, I'm puzzled; in a longish post you refer to your favorite "No Name" case lube and how diligently you searched for it. But you've said nothing that can help (or matters to) anyone, and then end up recognising that no one cares what you won't say. So, I wonder; "What's your point?"

1hole
06-04-2020, 12:02 PM
I'm in the Bag Balm users group. Have been for years. Not only good for a lube it is also good for your hands.

I've used two brands of bag balm, both from a farm supply store. Both work very well for case lube but the lubracating ingredient in both is wax and lanolin.

Good Cheer
06-05-2020, 05:10 PM
Got an old pimento jar with lanolin and alcohol in it.
The alcohol thins it down a little so it smears around easier.

JM7.7x58
06-05-2020, 08:51 PM
For full length resizing rifle brass or forming 7.7x58mm from LC 30-06 military brass, I use an old bottle of Sears air tool oil. It is a red colored oil that reminds me of Marvel Mystery Oil or ATF. I started using it because that was what was near at hand. I keep using it because it seems to work just fine.

5 to 10 drops in a zip lock bag, rub them around, wipe off the necks to avoid dents, and start forming.

Oily brass is no probem. I do all my reloading in the basement and have access to a huge double basin utility sink. All my brass gets washed with hot water, soap, and a bit of vinegar. My setup for brass washing is a three gallon bucket, an old steel broom handle for stirring, and a salad spinner for draining.

JM

Alferd Packer
06-07-2020, 04:12 AM
Anyone tried vegetable shortening like Crisco?
I also use it for bullet lube on light cast bullet loads like the subsonic loads.

Tazlaw
06-07-2020, 10:54 AM
I’ve started cleaning my brass twice since I got a Frankford Arsenal rotary wet tumbler with SS pins. It just doesn’t take very long, especially the second time. I will deprime with universal de primer die, then clean. I’ll then lube, size, trim, and maybe anneal. I have a salt bath annealer set up. After all that, I’ll clean again with hot water and dawn and little lemishine. Brass comes out perfect. I like the lanolin and alcohol mix, anywhere from 5:1 to 12:1. I just mix up a little at a time. The old saying “a little goes a long way” is true. Having a can of breakclean is handy if you start getting buildup.

1hole
06-07-2020, 08:19 PM
This is what I use, no need to clean off after either

https://www.homedepot.com/p/Klein-Tools-32-oz-Premium-Synthetic-Clear-Lubricant-51028/100660159

All of the several electric cable pulling lubes I've used are simply soft soaps. It does work pretty well as a case sizing lube but it's in the same general price range as a Tractor Supply Company store tin of udder/bag balm and that works slightly better. IMHO.

gwpercle
06-09-2020, 02:55 PM
Before you buy a big ole bottle of Castor Oil to make case lube with .... Smell It !
You just might not like the funky smell .
Lanolin , Bag Balm and Lee's Case Lube all smell much better , use one of them to mix up a spray case lube .
I like the Lee case lube because it's not greasy but a water soluble wax , when dry it will just wipe off with a dry or damp cloth .
Gary

SOFMatchstaff
06-10-2020, 02:49 PM
As I've post before, I use the Blue Magic conditioner and hair dressing available at the Wally world ethnic hair care section. It works great and smells nice. 50BMG to 22 Hornet and its cheep too. That being said, I still await the arrival of the Sooper Secret Slicker than Okra Snot "Guffey Grease" that seems to be hiding in the wings waiting for the moment to slide out and Looobe the heck out of anything that squeeks. God I miss my Herters catalog....

Conditor22
06-10-2020, 04:42 PM
If my lanolin / red heet doesn't work I use mink oil

prs
06-13-2020, 01:40 PM
I usually do this in batches that are about 3/4 full of Thumblers Tumbler tub (probably about a gallon or so. For easy stuff, after wet tumbling, I drain the dirty water in a sink basin, then rinse with cold water and stir around with my hands to be sure well drained. While brass is still surface wet I put a dab of Lee Case Lube on my hands and work through the brass again like Midas admiring his gold until well distributed; it gets into the necks very well. I dry in 4 tier food dehydrator and it does not take long at all, but I usually run it over night as I do this in bulk and not right when I am ready to reload. This works great for straight walled cases in steel dies and most necked cases in dies with carbide. School of hard nockes did teach met to increase the lube dose for some difficult bottle neck cases. I use a bigger dose of Lee Case Lube, like how the tooth paste commercials showed us how to overload our toothbrushes to increase their sales. ;-)

Bag balm is great for winter damaged hands, but it and oils and such are messy and require removal. I found the One Shot product to be a little messy to, but it worked great.

prs

Martin Luber
06-13-2020, 04:35 PM
I use olive oil. I put some on the lube pad and rub it in. A treatment last a long time.

Don't forget the garlic!

AnthonyB
06-13-2020, 07:03 PM
I will try try the ziploc bag trick to see if I can make it work on case necks. Thanks for that tip!
Tony

dryflash3
06-27-2020, 05:36 AM
I use the home maid version of Dillon spray lube.

1 part lanolin to 12 parts 99% alcohol in the same spray bottle that the Dillon came in.

To remove it I dry tumble in plain corn cob.

ebb
07-19-2020, 08:19 AM
I made home made after using Dillon and tried to copy it. Never occurred to me to use lanolin, although I have some lanolin now. I used yellow wire pulling lube and alcohol. The stuff is super cheap at the depot , but my first try was with some the electrician gave me at work. I think I found the directions on the internet some where.