What's your favorite BP pistol?

[Texas by God]

Let's see them! Mine is this Lyman .54 Plains pistol I built from a kit.
A few years back I killed a nice buck with it using 55grs of 3f and a prb. https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20180209/d67bfc797a28d2c4ff1e81f0c8ebacbf.jpghttps://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20180209/5ca293af726ff4cafeb18b415e96d42d.jpg

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

[Redd508]

That there is a fine lookin pistol.

Sent from my SM-N910V using Tapatalk

[Good Cheer]

213734

Just right now any ways, the favorite is a forty caliber 1851.

[RPRNY]

Rogers & Spencer (replica) with 45LC conversion cylinder
213735

And BPC: S&W Schofield Replica in 45LC

213736

[JoseBob]

Mine is the 1858 Remington. Sure handles better than the 1860 Army I had previously...

[rancher1913]

some days its a flinter single shot similar to your's and some days its the walker colt, the walker is fun to shot but it gets heavy after awhile. some days its some where in between.

[Texas by God]

Great stuff! Now I've heard of a .40 cal 51 Navy!

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

[Battis]

This one I'm actually taking with me - factory engraved Remington Beals .36.

[Beagle333]

My 1860's, for sure.

[Eddie2002]

Just picked up a Traditions Kentucky caplock pistol in .50 caliber. Don't think the thing had ever been shot much, the finish is almost perfect and it shoots great. I was able to hit the bulls eye at 25 yds off of a rest 3 out of 3 shots. Free hand I'm not that good yet;)

[Earlwb]

I have had several BP pistols over the years. But my "pirate" pistol as I call it, has been the most fun to play with. It is a .69 caliber flintlock pistol. I like to use .69 caliber mini balls in it. The bullets weigh 750 grains. I only load 40 to 50 grains of BP and it probably lobs the bullets out at around 600 fps. Yes the recoil is rather strong. What is really cool is that 16 gauge shotgun plastic power pistons fit perfectly. So being a smooth bore (cylinder bore), it does pretty well shooting shot too.

213762

[sharps4590]

A custom, 45 cal, Kentucky flintlock pistol. I have others to include a GP pistol like Texas posted and revolvers but that Kentucky flinter...it's just my favorite.

[siamese4570]

Not exactly traditional, but mine is a ruger old army. Most accurate pistol that I own.
Siamese4570

[Texas by God]

I love cap & ball revolvers but I gave my last one to a good friend. I've always had Colt replicas so my next one might be a Remington.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

[nightowl]

Navy Arms .36 Navy, traded it to friend who just loved it, Boy do I wish I had that one back.

[dondiego]

Thompson Center Patriot - both a .36 and a .45.

[Der Gebirgsjager]

Sure hope I'm not stretching the edges of this thread too far! To me, a true pistol is what Tex showed us in the first post, but Webster says: Pistol: "A short firearm intended to be aimed and fired with one hand." So I'm sticking my neck out here and saying that my favorite black powder pistol is a revolver, 1872 Colt conversion, this one's a replica in .38 Special. I'm pretty sure the .38s of the day were loaded with black powder--but the Special didn't come along until 1902, so the 1872 and the cat'rige (Texas talk) aren't exactly contemporaneous (but what's a mere 30 years?). Besides, just last night on TV I saw Willie using one of these with telling effect in "Outlaw Justice".
213822

Click to enlarge.

But, if you won't let me qualify with that one, then I'll have to fall back on this one as being my favorite.

213826

I've never owned a "true pistol" like shown in Post #1, but have worked on several. Most of them were Jukar brand, which was made in Spain. Why do they make me think of pirates?

If you really like the old 1851 Navy, then the .44 cal. shown in Post #3 is a great compromise between style, balance, and power. I've got one of those also, and it shoots a bit low and left. Enough so that one needs to aim at the upper right hand corner of the target to hit the center. Since there isn't much sight adjustment possible I was at kind of a loss as to what to do about the problem. A fellow who is very savvy about such things told me to increase the load by 10%, but I've never gotten around to trying it. Obviously, the day I was photographing these I mislabeled it as being an 1862, but it is an 1851 .44. Near as I can tell, they never existed in that caliber historically--but I'd be happy to hear I'm mistaken about that. This one is Pietta manufacture, purchased about 2003. Great idea, though.
213831

[Texas by God]

We call all handguns pistols where I come from so carry on!

[Texantothecore]

Pietta 1851 Navy .36 calibre. I will never sell or trade this revolver.

[RED333]

I picked this up from a member here. Dont see many correct hand flint pistols.

[condorjohn]

My 1860-1960 Centennial New Army.213958

[koger]

I have a Lyman .50 and .54 plains pistol, both are tack drivers but would be hard to choose between them and my Ruger Old Army, who happens to have a .45 Colt cylinder too. It shoots great as cap an ball, have taken 2 deer with it shooting 210gr slugs I cast up for it!!!

[Tracy]

Probably my ROA.

[tranders]

My favorite is my only BP pistol at the moment, a Pietta 1851 Navy in 36 caliber. It is a very nice looking revolver,but has been a source of frustration. After replacing nipples and a little file work on the hammer it seems to function ok for the time being.
My next will be a 1858 Remington .

[PhantomRider64]

Favorite BP pistol,,,my SAA 46 Colt.

Favorite muzzle loader pistol,,,any!!!

Sent from my SM-S920L using Tapatalk

[PhantomRider64]

Favorite BP pistol,,,my SAA 46 Colt.

Favorite muzzle loader pistol,,,any!!!

Sent from my SM-S920L using Tapatalk45 Colt,,,little keyboard.

Sent from my SM-S920L using Tapatalk

[fiberoptik]

Underhammer boot pistol. Thinking it was Hopkins & Allen? Were found in.36/.45. Then TC Patriot, Rugers fine caplock revolver.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ofitg]

The one I shoot most often is an old Uberti .36 Remington revolver..... it's built on a .44 frame, so the cylinder/chamber walls are extraordinarily thick (very handy for experimenting with homebrew powders).

[Harter66]

I really enjoy my Brass 1858 44 reproneverwas .
But I also like the Colts Dragoon repro I recently acquired .
I have several others but I expect these 2 will stay until I can't shoot them anymore .

[stubshaft]

Hands down...Ruger Old army

[Hanshi]

My favorite is the only pistol I own. It's a nice .50 flintlock and shoots better than I can.

https://image.ibb.co/jk2PXv/PICT0369_1_zps544bf87a.jpg (https://imgbb.com/)

[Texas by God]

My favorite is the only pistol I own. It's a nice .50 flintlock and shoots better than I can.

https://image.ibb.co/jk2PXv/PICT0369_1_zps544bf87a.jpg (https://imgbb.com/)Beautiful. The grip looks very practical.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

[Drm50]

I only got one, it's my favorite until I trade it off. I'm not into charcoal burners unless they are
originals.214296

[Good Cheer]

Hoorah for originals and the people who build them.

214461

214463

[Maint1517]

230655
My Pietta 1851 in .36 caliber

[Combat Diver]

1851 Navy

CD

[bob208]

my uberti 58 Remington in stainless steel with the .45 colt cylinder. I keep it loaded with six in the tool box in my shop. just in case.

[marlin39a]

My Uberti 51 Navy. I need ivoryex grips and a crossdraw holster for it. Wild Bill wannabe.

[Gtek]

Depends on what day it is! The mint mid run 1967 RNMA Centennial is the high, I really need to make myself shoot it and not just fondle it!

[BPSharps]

230714 Ruger Old Army for me...real accurate