Self guided elk adventure advice thread

[aarolar]

Little background info on my hunting buddies and I, we do self guided duck hunts all over the US. Usually a week but sometimes a long weekend, we go into an area blind and scout our butts off and hunt like fools usually put in days of leg work for one or two good mornings of hunting. Basically what I'm trying to say is we ain't afraid to work for our hunts.

Now that being said we want to do a self guided elk hunt out west, probably a week long but maybe more depending. My question is for people who live out that way or have done something similar to what we plan, and basically is it doable?

What state should we target and or what is the best piece of public land, best time of year ect?

Not looking for a handout here just some general guidelines and advice. I personally would be happy with a cow, no wants for a mount mainly want the experience.

Pic for attention Okalohama 2016...

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20170918/8b2b51f75e5ec1ded722389923a49150.jpg

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

[MyFlatline]

Will be interested to hear also. I have read that Colorado has the largest herd, just not trophy's and tags can be bought over the counter. This is what I have heard... I would like to do a couple hunts before I get to old and stove up to go. I will keep checking back.

[Beerd]

take a good look at the Sept-Oct issue of Montana Outdoors

http://fwp.mt.gov/mtoutdoors/

..

[MyFlatline]

take a good look at the Sept-Oct issue of Montana Outdoors

http://fwp.mt.gov/mtoutdoors/

..
Have it right here beside me....but getting drawn for Montana is not that easy. I got drawn for Mulie's this year, then found out they canceled elk in the area I am going ( Fergus/Petroleum Counties). I would have been a bit miffed if I had put in for Elk

[runfiverun]

it's doable in most places out here.
most are draws to get tags and you have to be careful of some units.
they like to sell 650 tags in areas that are totally weather dependent and have safe pathways through private property.
you can squeeze in between some of those property's up to state land but you need to know how to get there, and it's a long way around the mountain range finding that 1 little access.

[starmac]

It has been years since I have been there, but it used to be that in New Mexico you would list 4 choices on your application to draw a tag. Now it used to be if you put any hunt four your last choice, you DREW a COW tag pretty much every time. If things haven't changed and a group of guys listed a cow for their first choice, more than likely all of them would get one.
South of datil and quemada and all down through the Gila used to have lots of elk.

The best advice I have to see LOTS of elk, is go during deer season, you pretty much have to kick them out of the way while deer hunting. lol

The country I am talking about (do not remember the units) is very friendly for diy hunts, lots of public land, if you go into the wilderness it is walk in only.

[Beerd]

....but getting drawn for Montana is not that easy. I got drawn for Mulie's this year,

where? when?
..

[Minerat]

Colorado can be good but beware of the areas that have large numbers of left over draw tags. In most units they are a scam by the CPW to lure in unknowing hunters. Most of those areas have low numbers of elk and limited public access, or the elk are still up in the high country when the high volume season is on. Example areas 16, 161, 17, 171 (North park area around Walden) 2 years ago 1700+ left over tags and the elk were not down on to the reserve (in the park) until after Thanksgiving. Over the counter tags are mostly for Bull and in Colorado that means 4 points on one side or more and on public land that can be a challenge.

I look at an over the counter bull tags as having the same odds of hitting a progressive jackpot on a penny machine with a 50 cent play, and it only costs me $40.00. Out of state tags are in excess of $644 (but you get a fishing license too). If you want more info here is a link. http://cpw.state.co.us/thingstodo/Pages/BigGame.aspx

Don't mean to sound like a sourpuss on Colorado but you just need to be aware of the CPW's tricks. Do a lot of research on herd sizes, and harvest results for the area you are looking at. That can all be found on this link. http://cpw.state.co.us/thingstodo/Pages/Statistics-Elk.aspx

I did not draw an elk tag this year but got a doe tag so will spend 2 weeks in elk camp relaxing and fishing. Hope is snows 2 feet. Life is good.

[76 WARLOCK]

Minerat is correct.

[Landy88]

Duck country is a lot more accessible than elk country, and scouting for elk is not very doable in the few days that you mention.

Barring a source (paid guide or very knowledgeable and generous local mentor) of detailed local knowledge, I'd look on yours as a multiyear adventure. Your first seasons will, barring shear luck, be about learning and adapting to the country and scouting. And give yourselves as much time each season as you can.

[Djones]

Give yourself two weeks. Maybe even scout for a week before buying or putting in for a tag. Take a fishing pole if you are going this time of the year.

[skeeter2]

Some friends and I did that about 10 years ago. Colorado elk. Much easier to go for muzzle loader season as its still fairly warm and you need a bit less supplies. We slept in tents with warm sleeping bags. Took water and food along. There is a ton of national forest. We saw elk the first year but came home empty handed. The next year we got 3/4 tags filled, then 4/5, 2/3, 2/3 and 2/3. We always helped each other get the meat back to camp and shade the meat. We took a freezer and generator so we kept our meat cool and bug free. Have also had a couple Montana antelope hunts with my brother and we never came home with a tag unfilled. These trips are very doable for not much money. You also have the satisfaction of doing it yourself.

[duckey]

I'm on the right side of the country so can offer little advice....if you can find it....Tred Barta did a self guided elk hunt with his long bow in Colorado. He gave a lot of good advice as to going about it. He found a great spot with good sign and little pressure....didn't connect with one but saw lots of small bull elk. I know it's Tred Barta...he's is who he is but he offers great advice.

[aarolar]

I'm listening guys keep it coming, any suggestions on bare minimum guide services are welcome.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

[white eagle]

I don't know if you all have thought of this but how about a drop camp
outfitter takes you out and drops you in good elk country and you hunt on your own
use their horses and tents and other supplies but its not a guided hunt
i have done this and its well worth the expense

[elk hunter]

Don't bother coming to Oregon there are few areas with general season tags. The area I hunt is general season i.e. an over the counter tag, but the average success rate is 3% we beat that by a long margin but only because I've hunted the same area for over 50 years. Where ever you decide to go plan on the first year or two as scouting trips with only a small chance of bagging an elk. Be careful if you do get an elk as it almost always leads to a bad case of "elk fever" and there is no known cure, you just have to keep hunting them.

[aarolar]

I don't know if you all have thought of this but how about a drop camp
outfitter takes you out and drops you in good elk country and you hunt on your own
use their horses and tents and other supplies but its not a guided hunt
i have done this and its well worth the expenseYes I have considered this any suggestions for a good service to use?

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

[quilbilly]

You might look at Nevada but non-res. tags are expensive and drawing is similar to hitting the above mentioned progressive jackpot unless you choose your weapon and zone carefully. Some years back when I drew a mule deer muzzleloader tag and went solo into my area a few days before my season but during archery elk season, I was shocked at how few archers were around even though score able bugling bulls gathering cows were in sight always at close range (under 100 yards). A friend drew a similar tag two years ago at my suggestion to the same area and he made the same observation. Both of us were in sight of our vehicles too. The key was apparently not to hunt where conventional wisdom (or the TV shows) sent the Nevada hunters. Also some years back I had breakfast with a guide in the Tonopah area during a xctry ski adventure who made the remarkable statement that it was easier to find a 400 class bull in his area than a 180 class mule deer so charges accordingly. BTW - My friend and I both got score able bucks after the unforgettable experiences.

[MyFlatline]

where? when?
..

Fergus County, November 14th to 20th. Those are rough dates. We pull out of Florida on the 10th, figuring 3 1/3 days of driving..each way

[Eldon]

If you:

1. Are not in top physical condition
2. Are not under 40
3. Don't have horses or a gang to pack in and out
4. Have not stalked big game, knowing all that involves.
5. Don't own all the high country gear you will need.

Do it yourself is very hard, usually unsuccessful and potentially dangerous.

A good outfitter is worth every penny unless you just want a walk about.

Been there done that both ways. Happy to drive a 16 year old truck and spend the difference on outfitted hunts.

One of the best in my area, going sheep hunting with Dustin in 2 weeks !

http://www.trophymountainoutfitters.com/

[Beerd]

Fergus County, November 14th to 20th. Those are rough dates. We pull out of Florida on the 10th, figuring 3 1/3 days of driving..each way

I'll keep a lookout for an outfit with Florida plates.
ya never know, ya know?
..

[MyFlatline]

I'll keep a lookout for an outfit with Florida plates.
ya never know, ya know?
..

I got a friend that lives in Billings and has a place up there in Fergus. Mighty nice of him to invite me and a buddy up for a hunt. Keep yer eyes peeled for a white Dodge Ram with a topper....

[runfiverun]

be aware it has been snowing up here already.

I know that word is foreign to most people below the I-70 corridor.
but I have had almost an inch on the ground today down here in the valley, it stuck pretty well up higher and was there still when the sun went down.
I'd guess 3" at 6200 feet and more up higher.

[MyFlatline]

I have joked , you all will have record cold and snowfall this year, a Floridian is headed north to hunt in November :)

[MT Gianni]

We usually get a mild November in Montana. It rarely gets below -10 the first couple of weeks and often we see temps in the 40's and very occasionally 50's. The closer to Thanksgiving the more that can change. We finally got some moisture on the fires and I expect the snow will stay on top for quite a while from what they are saying. [7000 ft].

[Beagle333]

If you:

1. Are not in top physical condition
2. Are not under 40
3. Don't have horses or a gang to pack in and out
4. Have not stalked big game, knowing all that involves.
5. Don't own all the high country gear you will need.

Do it yourself is very hard, usually unsuccessful and potentially dangerous.

True. This leaves me out. Being 53 and partly crippled, somebody would have to give me a chair in a barn and lead an elk out into a field in front of the barn window and let me shoot it. LOL

[quilbilly]

There are always Roosevelt elk when you can hunt in sideways rain. I have found that the November modern firearm coastal elk season marks the beginning of the monsoon season in the NW. I once followed a herd with several shootable bulls as fast as I could drive down the logging road just to get out of the forest alive due to falling trees in hurricane winds. We all escaped alive - barely

[runfiverun]

I don't know if I could take another record snowfall year. :lol:

just be aware of the weather, it's not what your used to and can change pretty quickly.
our night time temps are in the mid 20's right now.
it will probably warm up some in a week or 2, or maybe not [shrug]

tomorrow is check the tire chains, tow chains, and come-along day since our Deer hunt starts in about 3 weeks.

[sixshot]

Lamar, quit trying to scare these guys, the Fish & Game assured the families of the last bunch from Florida that they would be found before Christmas.......of 2019!

Dick

[MyFlatline]

Thanks for the concerns, I knew it was gonna be a bit "nippy".. :biggrin:

Trust me, We are packing for 3 seasons, cold, real cold and damn cold. If it hits bitter cold, I'll stoke the fire ....

[Djones]

I just got back from northern Colorado national forest bow hunt. I was calling for dad, and this guy and his buddy came in behind me.

204458

It was into the low 80s in the afternoon and mid 30s in the morning.

[Eldon]

True. This leaves me out. Being 53 and partly crippled, somebody would have to give me a chair in a barn and lead an elk out into a field in front of the barn window and let me shoot it. LOL

Not true, with a good outfitter. In 14' I could not use my super hard to get upper Green Elk tag. Turned it in for a disabled vet, who got a good outfitter and killed a 6x7 from his track chair. A horny bull is not terribly smart or bullet proof IF you have a good outfitter.

[runfiverun]

I'm not tryin to run him off Dick. :lol:
he can park next to the guy's from Oregon and Cal. at the top of Georgetown canyon if he want's to.
the guy's from Oregon just look like child molesters, they are kind of tolerable after you see them 2-3 times.
the one even said Hi to me the next morning after I pulled their truck back on the road.

[Minerat]

I'm 64 and still hunt elk on public land. Helped pack one out last year. One quarter, 3 hr to go 2 miles, (weren't in no rush, camp wasn't going any where). I just take my time. Trust me I'd prefer to kill one next to road or trail so I can get a truck or ATV to it but they are where they are. I have also found out that elk tastes the same whether it is 10 mile back in or 30 seconds from a road. For the low elevations guys, give yourselves a couple of 3 days to get acclimated to the elevations in elk camp before you start strenuous activities. Attitude sickness can really fudge up a good hunt. Check it out. http://www.altitude.org/altitude_sickness.php