PDA

View Full Version : Sound of live taps fades from soldiers' services



M-Tecs
04-09-2017, 07:00 PM
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/sound-of-live-taps-fades-from-soldiers-services/ar-BBzC8gg?li=BBnb7Kz&ocid=edgsp

Every morning before work, and before sunrise (http://http//on.thec-l.com/2oNT3aa), David Dodson sits in his car, garage door closed, and practices playing his trumpet for 30 minutes.
He always finishes with taps — a chilling, 24-note salute that is traditionally played by a lone bugler or trumpeter at funerals of U.S. military veterans.
It is the only song the 49-year-old Dodson can play, and it is the only song he cares about playing.
Six months ago, he began learning the trumpet when he discovered that veterans and their families were no longer guaranteed a live version of taps.
Often a recording is used, instead. And sometimes a person pretends to play taps as the electronic version is heard.
“I just found that unacceptable,” says Dodson, a Southaven resident who enlisted in the Air Force in 1988 and served 6 1/2 years. He spent his military time stateside, helping maintain nuclear missiles aimed at possible threats to our country.
“The playing of taps is usually going to be one of the last things that a family hears at their loved one’s funeral,” he says. “Anybody will tell you that it sounds better when played live. I think every veteran, decorated or not, deserves that show of respect.”
In February, on Super Bowl Sunday, Dodson passed his taps audition over the phone and became a member of Bugles Across America, a not-for-profit founded in 2000 by Marine veteran Tom Day.
Day’s action was a result of legislation passed by Congress stating that a veteran has the right to at least two uniformed military members to fold the flag and play a recording of taps.
“Mr. Day calls the recording ‘stolen dignity’ — even if it works properly, and that is not always the case,” Dodson says.
Bugles Across America has more than 4,000 volunteers who play "taps for free at veterans’ services in all 50 states." That may sound like a lot, but more than a million veterans are expected to die this year.
Mississippi has 20 buglers. It is the home of 220,389 veterans; 40,461 are ages 75 and older. That is more than 2,000 veterans per bugler in that age bracket alone. Obviously, more volunteers are needed.
“I’m trying to get word out the best I can,” Dodson says. “But I’m not a music person. I don’t know a lot of musicians. I have no way of identifying those who can play a bugle, a trumpet or a flugelhorn. I’m just a guy who picked up a trumpet last year, wanting to be part of the solution.”
'I'm there out of respect'
One of Dodson’s neighbors, a World War II and Korean War veteran, died about a year ago.
“After I heard they wanted a military funeral, I helped the family put it together,” Dodson says. “When I heard they weren’t going to have a bugler, I called Bugles Across America and was able to get a live version. I saw how impactful it was.”
He received a letter from the family, thanking him for helping arrange it.
“It just got me to thinking that surely I could learn how to play the trumpet well enough to play taps,” he says.
He practiced on his own and also received tips from three experienced trumpeters. One of them was 61-year-old Bob Putman of Hernando, who joined Bugles Across America two years ago. Putman grew up in Houston, Texas, and played trumpet in his middle school and high school bands.
“I really have a lot of admiration for David,” Putman says. “I let him borrow an instructional book. He came over to the house a couple of times. He would send me recordings, and I would send him suggestions.
“To pass the audition as quickly as he did and never having played before, that took a lot of dedication.”
Already, Dodson has played at two services.
“Both of them were inside,” he says. “There is a lot of pressure involved. I know there is no do-over. It’s a one-time thing for that veteran and the family. I didn’t sleep a whole lot the two nights leading up to it.”
He drove six hours round-trip to the Delta town of Sunflower. When the color guard members removed the flag from the casket and stretched it out, they stood at attention, which was Dodson’s cue.
From a spot just outside the church’s front doors, Dodson slightly angled the trumpet so it wouldn’t be deafening to those inside.
“I did OK,” he says.
The second one, in the middle of March, was much more difficult.
“The first one, we were at the first part of the service,” he says. “But at the second one we were at the end. I heard people talk about this man, a Vietnam veteran, Purple Heart recipient. I found myself getting emotionally involved, and I don’t think I did as well.”
Putman prefers to play at graveside, where he can detach himself from the ceremony.
“I’m typically at the cemetery before anybody else gets there,” he says. “I stand away from those who gather. When it comes time to play, I close my eyes and concentrate on nothing but the music.
“I’m honored to do it. But I play, and then I leave. I don’t wait around for feedback because it’s not about me. I’m there out of respect for the veteran.”
But Putman can’t always avoid attention. He recently played for a 38-year-old retired Marine captain, who died of cancer. He was married with seven children. Putman saw the family every week at church.
“That Sunday after the funeral, people were coming up and saying how nice it was and how much everybody appreciated it,” Putman says. “All I could think about was his family and how young he was.”
Tony Taylor, 56, of Madison appreciates the efforts of people like Dodson and Putman. Taylor was a Marine staff sergeant who served six years, including stints in Lebanon, during the 1980s.
"A recording at a veteran's funeral? I just find that so insulting," says Taylor, a third-generation Marine. "It's like putting them aside. You would think all the money this country spends on frivolous things, we could assign buglers to play for them.
"But I can see how someone who never served would say, 'just send a recording.' Because they don't understand what taps means to those of us who have served. I actually spent time on a burial detail and did seven services. When they played taps ... well, that's one of the few times a Marine is allowed to cry. It's hard to explain all the emotions that go through you when it's played."
'We simply need more people'
Putman says he could play at a funeral “almost every day.” The demand is that enormous.
“I struggle with saying I can’t do it,” he says, “but I have a job. I can’t take off all the time.”
A vice president for a manufacturing company in Hernando and Tunica, Putman says he will play at a service “if it involves one of my church members, if it’s on a weekend or if I happen to be off that day.
“We simply need more people who can help take care of all the requests.”
Putman, who is not a veteran, joined Bugles Across America after watching a couple of YouTube clips about recordings being played at military funerals.
“It disgusted me,” he says. “The recording sounds so puny.”
Volunteers consist of men and women, boys and girls. Candidates need to pass an audition with Reagan Moon, acting state director of Mississippi and director of Louisiana. Moon lives in Bossier City, Louisiana. The audition can be done in person, via Skype, a phone call or an audio tape.
Volunteers provide their own instruments and transportation. They are required to maintain "high moral and ethical standards," according to the organization's website, www.buglesacrossamerica.org (http://www.buglesacrossamerica.org/).
“No, you don’t get paid for this — at least not in money,” Dodson says. “Just knowing that you did something important for someone who served our country and gave that family something they will remember the rest of their lives … that’s worth more than money to me.”
Follow Billy Watkins on Twitter: @BillyWatkins11

DCP
04-09-2017, 07:19 PM
Very good cause.

Handloader109
04-10-2017, 08:20 AM
Id heard there were recordings being used, hadn't heard of this group. Kind of sorry I sold my trumpet a few yrs ago.

w5pv
04-10-2017, 08:42 AM
Taps by a live bugler is the proper send off for those who served.

smoked turkey
04-10-2017, 10:43 AM
Many many decades ago as a young high school trumpet player I was asked a couple of times to play at the graveside. On one of the times there was an old gentleman who was back in the edge of the woods quite a ways back from the grave side who did the echo. His was more raspy, and not as polished as mine. However his was from the heart and was very moving. He had something that I didn't have and it left me as a young boy with an admiration for the old guy. It was very moving.

FISH4BUGS
04-10-2017, 12:58 PM
My Dad, a 25 year veteran officer in the Army, is buried at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas National Cemetery. He fought in the Pacific in WW2. He died 55 years ago in the service of his country. Taps was played at his funeral as well as the gun salute. I still cannot listen to it without tears. It was probably the most profound moment of my life at 14 years old, and has been ever since. Not having a live bugler is shameful to the memory of someone that was a veteran.

Blackwater
04-10-2017, 03:06 PM
At my cousin's funeral, they had a live bugler, a drill team and of course, the two who folded the flag. It was the crispest performance I've ever seen! Bob spent over 40 years in the USAF/ANG and was a loadmaster. He worked most of his years in Houston at the Aerospace center, and loved his work like most of us will only ever wish to. His funeral was one of those "celebrations of life" that are a real pleasure and reassurance to attend.

But nothing will ever create the tingling sensations that "Taps" can when well played by a good musician, who is also moved by what he's playing. I'm so glad and thankful for the men who performed so admirably and respectfully at Bob's funeral. He fought cancer for 16 years I think it was, and fought it valiantly and with both confidence and resignation - a bit of a contradiction, I know, but that's how he did it.

Anyone who isn't moved by the playing of "Taps" just isn't fully human, IMO.

Finster101
04-10-2017, 08:48 PM
"Anyone who isn't moved by the playing of "Taps" just isn't fully human, IMO."


It is truly one of the most emotional songs that you will ever play or hear. Often very tough to get through.

Hardcast416taylor
04-10-2017, 09:00 PM
I also tear up when hearing `taps` being played in reference to my late Son an E-5 Marine. There is an old retired merchant sailor in a small town rear me that plays the bag pipes. He is in great demand to assist a `tap`s bugler at grave side services kilt and all, talk about not a dry eye in the crowd.Robert

Bzcraig
04-10-2017, 09:25 PM
Unfortunately, my wife's grandfather, retired Navy, only got a recording when buried at Riverside National Cemetery in 1992. Things have gotten much better since then about burying our service members.

West Creek
04-12-2017, 09:49 PM
In my 49 years I've been to a few funerals with military send offs. Most times taps was played by a recording or one of those player bugles. The couple of times it was played live brought with it an appreciation for the skill required.
My dad passed last August and my sister arranged for his military honors. For the first time in my life I heard it at its best. Two bugler's played it with echo and did so flawlessly. It was very moving to say the least.

shoot-n-lead
04-12-2017, 11:07 PM
My Dad died 7yrs ago...Taps was played, live...one of the things that I will NEVER forget.

birch
04-13-2017, 08:58 AM
I passed this information and the website along to our local high school band director. Her father was a Vietnam Vet. When he died, the "bugler" was present, but there was a small speaker and devise in the bell of the trumpet. The person acted like they were playing taps, but it was very apparent that the person was a stage prop. She was devastated.

She knows of at least three trumpet players who plan on enrolling in Taps For Veterans. She also sent me a thank you for showing her the program. So, I will extend the thank you to those who highlighted this idea on this website.

bedbugbilly
04-15-2017, 01:35 PM
Around here, when Taps is required, they usually use a high school student who is good on the trumpet but if one is not available, then I have heard a recording is used. I have also been to several funerals where military honors were given, that a recording was used on - just not the same.

I'm just curious . . . most I've been to have been played on the trumpet. Is the trumpet usually used now or are there some which actually play Taps on a bugle?

There is just something about Taps that leaves a lump in the throat . . . a final "honor earned".

jonp
04-15-2017, 08:21 PM
The only tunes that tear me up are Taps and Amazing Grace on Bagpipes. My grandfather went ashore at Omaha and passed away when I was a kid. At his funeral a local kid played taps at the end from the other side of a hill. Heartbreaking. I've been privileged to attend a flagline at a number of military funerals to show our respect for the fallen and the deceased. Taps makes me tear up every time.

birch
04-16-2017, 12:04 AM
I usually find something go count to keep my mind occupied whenever taps is played. There is power in those four notes. ..and the lyrics are incredible as well.

Day is done, gone the sun,
From the lake, from the hills, from the sky;
All is well, safely rest, God is nigh.

Fading light, dims the sight,
And a star gems the sky, gleaming bright.
From afar, drawing nigh, falls the night.

Thanks and praise, for our days,
'Neath the sun, 'neath the stars, neath the sky;
As we go, this we know, God is nigh.

Sun has set, shadows come,
Time has fled, Scouts must go to their beds
Always true to the promise that they made.

While the light fades from sight,
And the stars gleaming rays softly send,
To thy hands we our souls, Lord, commend.