Which is your favorite?

[Armyguy80]

Ok just a quick poll out there. I have been shooting my Glock 23 for a while, recently picked up a Springfield Armory XD 9 SC in 9mm and loved it so much I got the XD in .40 with a 4 inch bbl. In addition to handling I like the way it disassembles IMHO much easier than a glock. To spice things up lets throw in the Smith and Wesson M&P series. Which one and why?

[subsonic]

Of the three styles of pistol mentioned, I prefer Glock. The other two are just copies of a Glock. I'd rather have the real thing. The grip angle and shape points better for me. I have seen all of the guns torture tested and don't think the other two will take the abuse that a Glock will. Tenifer.

[Ed K]

Springfield XD

Why? A Glock 21 does not fit my hand at all. A XD 45 is just right.

[David LaPell]

I can say that I like the way a Smith M & P fits in my hand but I have never fired one, I don't like the Springfield XD at all, and our duty gun is a Glock 21 and I can shoot the darn thing quite well, getting 250's back to back in our annual qualifications, but none of them can ever take the place of my Smith 27.

[bigboredad]

I prefer the xd for the way it fits in my hand and I shoot it much better fit. Tennifer Melonite what's the difference. I'm not fond of the glock kool aide either:popcorn:

[white eagle]

none of the above :holysheep
why :?:
hate looking for brass [smilie=b:

[subsonic]

Do you know what an HS2000 is?

[Love Life]

If I am going to own a black 50/50 plastic/metal pistol that is as thick as a phone book then it is going to have a big fat "G" stamped into the grip.

I'm with subsonic on this one. Having shot all three I prefer my glock any day of the week. Of course I have shot my glocks alot over the years so I am very comfortable with them.

[subsonic]

Besides, only glocks come in 10mm.

[Love Life]

Besides, only glocks come in 10mm.

One day I am going to have to get me a 10MM.

[Armyguy80]

Do you know what an HS2000 is?

It is for all intents and purposes the Springfield XD...

[MtGun44]

I'm a 1911 guy, but of the three you mentioned, I like the S&W M&P by far the best.

I really, seriously dislike the Glock grip angle, grip bumps and trigger stroke. But other than
that they are OK . . . . .NOT! The XD is far above the Glock ergonomically for me, but the
fact that they won't feed SWCs puts them on the totally unacceptable list for me. I do hear
that the newer XDs may feed SWCs. Don't even think about changing out an extractor on
an XD, though!

Bill

[LUBEDUDE]

Sold my G-21 to get an XD because of a better fit and I like the grip safety.

Like the M&P, would like to try before I buy.

[thegreatdane]

I like em all, and own all but the MP. That one is coming soon. I borrowed one for a few range trips and thought to myself: why don't I own one of these already?!

[x101airborne]

Well, I own a glock and used to own an XD. Sold the XD to a buddy, so it is not really gone. I always carry my glock in my offshore boat with me. We went out in some NASTY seas and got water all inside the boat. Came home sick as **** and did not clean the boat right away. The supposedly "dry box" where I keep the weapon was holding around 8 inches of water and I did not check it. That glock stayed in there for around two months until I went to get my e-purb to check the batteries. My buddy saw it and said "Do you think it will ever work?" I said dunno, and emptied the clip into the dirt. Yep, good to go. You will never let an XD sit in corrosive salt water and still survive. NEVER.

[Aces an Eights]

Have no experience with them yet, but I'd probably choose a Glock 34 or a H&K USP Elite in the hope a longish barrel would help me shoot better than my buddies with their rusty CZs and Tanfogs.

[NickSS]

I own a lock 17 for some years now but it is not a favorite pistol of mine. I have handled the other two and they both have better feels to them but personally I really do not like any of them. I like browning HP, Colt 1911s, CZ 75, and Berretta Cougar 8000. All of this is basically due to superior trigger pulls compared to guns with the so called safe action.

[big dale]

I have never claimed to be in love with the Glock...I bought my 10 mm back in the mid 90's. Three other Glocks and a bunch of spare barrels have been added since then. I don't consider them to be particularly accurate compared to any of my Ruger revolvers, but they always go bang and there is a lot to be said for that. There is always at least one and a few spare clips within reach. They just don't put a big ole grin on my face like my Super Blackhawk does everytime I think about it.

Have fun with this stuff.

Big Dale

[subsonic]

Only 33 parts in a glock and anyone can replace any of them without much more than a punch and hammer. I have seen one detail stripped with only a set of car keys.