PDA

View Full Version : Not paying $30 for a Lee crimp die



rtracy2001
02-01-2011, 12:20 AM
I have had good results with the lee rifle crimp dies. So much so that I want to try one on my 8mm-06. Popular wildcat though the 8mm-06 is, it is still a wildcat and as such requires a custom built crimp die. Lee offers this service for $25 +$5 shipping, and I have to send them a dummy round first. I get the die set when they feel like making it.

I'm cheap and $30 for a $15 die just doesn't sit well with me.

I got to thinking the other day, (first problem) and figure I should be able to modify a 30-06 crimp die to work for the 8mm-06. All that is really required is to drill/ream out the collet a little bit to accept the 8mm boolit.

Am I dreaming, or is it that simple?

how hard is it to drill out one of those collets? anyone ever done it?

heathydee
02-01-2011, 12:49 AM
I would get hold of an 8x57 Mauser Factory Crimp Die and machine up a 6mm thick washer to sit on top of the shellholder . The dies work by bottoming on the shellholder which pushes the collet up into the taper . All that needs to be done is to push the collet 6mm earlier , that being the difference between the 8x57 and the 8mm-06 .

imashooter2
02-01-2011, 01:12 AM
It isn't $30 for a $15 die, it's pretty darn cheap custom work. The time table you have a right to be unhappy about, but not the price.

I think to make your own from an aught six die, you'd have to have the collet fingers compressed when drilling. Not sure what that jig looks like.

Blackhawk Convertable
02-01-2011, 01:37 AM
Would it be possible to get both the 8mm and 30-06 crimp dies and switch the crimp inserts so the 8mm is in the 30-06?

jimkim
02-01-2011, 08:01 AM
Would it be possible to get both the 8mm and 30-06 crimp dies and switch the crimp inserts so the 8mm is in the 30-06?

It works with mine.

heathydee
02-01-2011, 06:08 PM
It works with mine.

The crimp inserts will exchange between die bodies which are visually identical . The difference in length between the 8x57 and the 30-06 crimp inserts is 6mm . An 8x57 crimp insert in a 30-06 die body will not crimp an 8mm-06 .

starmac
02-01-2011, 06:23 PM
I would think for them to be able to make a profit at that price they would have to be able to set up and run the die out in 15 minutes or less.

troyboy
02-01-2011, 06:55 PM
"It isn't $30 for a $15 die, it's pretty darn cheap custom work. The time table you have a right to be unhappy about, but not the price."


+1

30CAL-TEXAN
02-01-2011, 08:07 PM
I ordered a custom 7.5 French factory crimp die from lee and I had the die in my hands 1 week to the day from putting the check in the mail box.

I'm not sure if that is typical of the FCD custom services or if they just happen to keep over runs from non-stock calibers that they have made in the past.

On another note: if you could actually Frankenstein one from the 2 calibers mentioned above, wouldn't you just be spending the $30 anyway for the 2 dies?

rtracy2001
02-02-2011, 12:59 AM
On another note: if you could actually Frankenstein one from the 2 calibers mentioned above, wouldn't you just be spending the $30 anyway for the 2 dies?

I plan on buying a crimp die for the 30-06 anyway, so that price stays the same. I could order an extra crimp collet at a cost of $9, making the total about $30 for esentially two dies. Or I could just spend $35 and get two complete dies. (come to think of it, I need an 8x57 die anyway too.)

If I let them do the custom work I spend $50, so no it isn't a huge difference.

holding the collet closed while maching shouldn't be temendously difficult as Lee sends a holding jig with the collet (the die body). It would not be difficult to thread the die into a press and raise the ram to the top of the stroke while maching the collet.

Maybe it is just the cumulative effect of an extra $15 here, an extra $30 there, a probable 5 year pay freeze (Thank you Washington) and not having the equipment to just make things myself, so I am at the complete mercy of others. That and lets face it, custom work or not, what is Lee going to do? They will take a 30-06 collet and ream it out to the 8mm spec, slap it in a standard die body and send it out the door. Odds are the collet will say "8mm XX -06" on it. :rantoff:

Too bad the custom die work isn't like the custom mold work in that if you get enough orders they will waive the setup fee, and it ends up just about the same as a standard item

1hole
02-02-2011, 11:23 AM
"Am I dreaming, or is it that simple?"

It is that simple.


"how hard is it to drill out one of those collets? anyone ever done it? "

I have modified Lee collet crimpers but drilling isn't the way to go and finding a correct diameter bit may be impossible anyway (I ain't gonna do the research to see).

You need to have the collet fingers firmly closed when you work so do it with the die in the press, lever down and collet pushed up moderately hard. Use a common taper reamer to enlarge the hole. Stop cutting when the hole is maybe 10-15 thou larger than the final diameter of your case neck. If that happens to not be quite large enough you can ream it out a tad more. Work careful, it's very hard to put metal back if you go too far at any stage and buying another crimp die to save half the cost sorta negates your efforts!

deltaenterprizes
02-02-2011, 12:25 PM
Custom die at off the shelf price? Obamanomics at work or how to go bankrupt one customer at a time. Better yet why don't they just PAY YOU to take the die!
At $30 that die is a bargain at twice the price.

lead-1
02-02-2011, 06:48 PM
I would get hold of an 8x57 Mauser Factory Crimp Die and machine up a 6mm thick washer to sit on top of the shellholder . The dies work by bottoming on the shellholder which pushes the collet up into the taper . All that needs to be done is to push the collet 6mm earlier , that being the difference between the 8x57 and the 8mm-06 .


I measured out the difference between .308 and .30-06 and made a spacer to use .308 FCD on .30-06 shells. You have the extra step of putting the spacer on and off of each round but it works great and saved me the cost of an extra die.

heathydee
02-02-2011, 07:44 PM
I measured out the difference between .308 and .30-06 and made a spacer to use .308 FCD on .30-06 shells. You have the extra step of putting the spacer on and off of each round but it works great and saved me the cost of an extra die.

Glad I could help

bruce drake
12-04-2017, 11:18 PM
I measured out the difference between .308 and .30-06 and made a spacer to use .308 FCD on .30-06 shells. You have the extra step of putting the spacer on and off of each round but it works great and saved me the cost of an extra die.

bingo! Seems like this is the easiest answer if you have a 8x57 FCD die already.

earlmck
12-05-2017, 02:27 AM
My 30/30 fc die also works for my 32 Special (they must build them with considerable slop). Just possible the '06 fc die will crimp the 8mm/06 without further ado. You have any buddies with a '06 die you could try?

rtracy2001
12-05-2017, 08:03 AM
My 30/30 fc die also works for my 32 Special (they must build them with considerable slop). Just possible the '06 fc die will crimp the 8mm/06 without further ado. You have any buddies with a '06 die you could try?

Wow, haven't thought about this thread in ages. I did pick up a 30-06 crimp die a while back, so I may just give that a shot.

RED BEAR
12-05-2017, 09:28 PM
As a retired machinist I can tell you I wouldn't even turn on a machine for thirty dollars . thirty dollars is extremely cheap for this service. And that is coming from the cheapest person on earth. ( honary title given by wife)

popper
12-06-2017, 12:04 AM
So how do you get the insert out?

bangerjim
12-06-2017, 12:18 AM
Hey. It's only money. And last time I checked, coffins do not have side pockets!

Buy what you need when you can.........while you can!

I sure do.

EDG
12-06-2017, 01:16 AM
I have had good results with the lee rifle crimp dies. So much so that I want to try one on my 8mm-06. Popular wildcat though the 8mm-06 is, it is still a wildcat and as such requires a custom built crimp die. Lee offers this service for $25 +$5 shipping, and I have to send them a dummy round first. I get the die set when they feel like making it.

I'm cheap and $30 for a $15 die just doesn't sit well with me.

I got to thinking the other day, (first problem) and figure I should be able to modify a 30-06 crimp die to work for the 8mm-06. All that is really required is to drill/ream out the collet a little bit to accept the 8mm boolit.

Am I dreaming, or is it that simple?

how hard is it to drill out one of those collets? anyone ever done it?

You are totally unrealistic. Apparently you know nothing of the design of the crimping collet.

john.k
12-06-2017, 03:15 AM
I also would like to know if/how the insert comes out.From Lees drawing in the Cat,it appears that the collet fingers have to be compressed to pass over the ridge in the housing.But its also possible that the collet is captive by a swaged lip,which would have to be cut off.Anyhoo,ive got no use for the crimping,but lee collets are verrry soft,(compared to similar collets),and reworking them can be done with a file,if nothing better is available.

jimkim
12-06-2017, 09:06 AM
I also would like to know if/how the insert comes out.From Lees drawing in the Cat,it appears that the collet fingers have to be compressed to pass over the ridge in the housing.But its also possible that the collet is captive by a swaged lip,which would have to be cut off.Anyhoo,ive got no use for the crimping,but lee collets are verrry soft,(compared to similar collets),and reworking them can be done with a file,if nothing better is available.Just pull it out. It's held in by friction from a spring steel ring.

Sent from my VS880 using Tapatalk

EDG
12-06-2017, 11:03 AM
The collet is just held in place by friction from a cheap wire ring.
Just pull it out.
You cannot rework the fingers with a file. There is a small lip that can only be machined before the collet is split.

lucifers
12-06-2017, 02:37 PM
30 bucks ? pages and pages over 30 bucks ? I drink more wine in a week than that and all I have to show for it are 2 empty bottles !

We got along for most of the 20th century w/o Lee crimp dies, I'm sure we can in the 21st. (Although I have a bunch and like them)

Just a thought, but an 8mm06 reamer costs a lot more than 30 bucks --- maybe shuda left it an 8x57 ???

Mytmousemalibu
12-06-2017, 03:07 PM
I pieced together a collet neck sizing die for 7.62x54R from Lee parts since there is no such thing off the shelf. I used a combination of .303 British and 7.5x55 Swiss if memory serves me right. There was some very minor machining involved too.

EDG
12-06-2017, 09:14 PM
30 bucks ? pages and pages over 30 bucks ? I drink more wine in a week than that and all I have to show for it are 2 empty bottles !

We got along for most of the 20th century w/o Lee crimp dies, I'm sure we can in the 21st. (Although I have a bunch and like them)

Just a thought, but an 8mm06 reamer costs a lot more than 30 bucks --- maybe shuda left it an 8x57 ???

No the cost delta is only $15. There is no proof it is even necessary.
I like the Lee factory crimp dies for rifle ammo but I only use them for autoloaders.

texassako
12-06-2017, 09:33 PM
All of Lee's dies that are collet types are easy to mod. You just have to make the collet close at the right spot and the right amount. Trim a bit or add a bit, pick the same length cartridge, open it up a little, use a bigger cartridges fcd and put it on a spacer, etc. I need to load some 7.5x54 French now, and wouldn't you know there is a standard 7.62x54 FCD. 54mm = 54mm

EDG
12-07-2017, 12:20 PM
All of Lee's dies that are collet types are easy to mod. You just have to make the collet close at the right spot and the right amount. Trim a bit or add a bit, pick the same length cartridge, open it up a little, use a bigger cartridges fcd and put it on a spacer, etc. I need to load some 7.5x54 French now, and wouldn't you know there is a standard 7.62x54 FCD. 54mm = 54mm

Your claim is not accurate. You may modify one of the dies by some crude method but it is not likely to work.
That is based on 10000 hours of running an engine lathe followed by an engineering degree and 40 years of manufacturing engineering in precision machined parts design and production.

JonB_in_Glencoe
12-07-2017, 12:45 PM
I love it, when an old thread is revived :bigsmyl2:

I placed one order for two custom dies from Lee back in 2013 for my 257Rx6.5 (it's kind of a wildcat?), a Lee collet Neck sizer die and the Lee Collet FCD. It did take quite a while to get them, mostly due to the frantic buying after the sandy hook shooting, which lasted almost the whole year of 2013. BUT, what I noticed (and the reason I'm commenting), is the quality of workmanship I got was much better than the usual standard/stock Lee dies I have bought. Making the higher price worth it, IMHO.

robg
12-07-2017, 06:55 PM
How much would it cost to make a one off? $30 seems like a bargain to me.

DanLee
12-11-2017, 07:14 PM
The real cheapskates among us just hold the cartridge upside down in the die so the crimp fingers push the case mouth into the crimp cannulure.

texassako
12-11-2017, 09:10 PM
Your claim is not accurate. You may modify one of the dies by some crude method but it is not likely to work.
That is based on 10000 hours of running an engine lathe followed by an engineering degree and 40 years of manufacturing engineering in precision machined parts design and production.

Please explain, I would love to know why my modified dies do not work. The OP could easily stack a 6mm (.2362") spacer on the shell holder to use an 8x57mm FCD ($15 on Ebay) with the 8mm-06 if he wanted, and amazingly two 1/2" washers out of my parts drawer equal .235". Ugly=maybe, works=yes. All he would be doing is changing the length of the collet from the 8x57's 57mm to 8mm-06's 63mm to have the collet close on the case mouth. The FCD leaves a funny looking crimp if you go from the top though, reverse taper sorta.