I know this is kind of silly coming from a new gun owner that's had a great experience with my Model 10, and wouldn't trade it for anything. However, after some reading through more of Elmer Keith's "Sixguns", I've been doing some research on the wide variety of Single Action Army derivations, as well as a little on the real deal, and think I may get one in the future.
I think the least I can do is try a friend's SAA derivative, which would be the most reasonable action to do before dumping cash into a beaut.
In terms of looks and make and model, I think the style that best fits my aesthetic and "wheelygun cool" looks is a 4.5 to 5.5 Inch barreled model (prefer 5.5) with their standard (Not Bisley) Grips in the classic caliber of .45 Colt. I'm partial to its standard sight, but target sights would be fairly welcome as well.
In terms of finish, I'd be OK with a case hardened or blued finish. Stainless would be nice if I could get it for the same price as a blued model. However, I'm not sure about any additional procedures needed to care for them. There's no need for any engravings or fancy stuff on the piece. I'd be looking for something in a mostly classic feel to it, without being showy.
I've had a detailed look at Ruger and Uberti's websites, and i've got a list of models that I find pleasing.
From Uberti's Websites, I'm liking, all 5.5 inch:
Chisholm, Hombre, El Patrón (Blued Model).
From Ruger:
Ruger Vaquero, Ruger New Vaquero, Ruger Blackhawk Convertible.
I haven't really looked into Cimarron or Colt, but I probably will in the future.
I'd love to hear of your takes on your Colt SAA/variant experience. Are there any manufacturers to avoid? I'm looking to get something that can reliably fire modern .45 Colt with no trouble. That is, if I ever get one. Perhaps I could get one from an owner that needs a little extra vault space as long as they have taken good care of it and it fits my wants.