I posted a question and some results in the Muzzle Loading forum on the site here and it concerned my Creedmoor shaped bullets tumbling. This is with a Pedersoli Gibbs and also a copy I made with the same barrel dimensions. They were okay for several weeks and then after a month had passed they acted weird. The powder load, velocity, wad and loading methodology had not changed so finally I pulled out the calipers and found the 0.449 diameter bullets had now become 0.446! These are BACO molded grease groove 540 gain so I tried some of my paper patch smooth sided and they had also shrunk 0.003 so I figured it must be the alloy? I pulled out my Lee hardness tester and it showed a BHR of 14 so according to what I could read, they should not have shrunk as much?
I tried knurling the grease groove bullets by rolling some between two new and very course flat files from my friends at Harbor Freight and after 3 trips down the file the OD was back to 0.449. The lube grooves were not disturbed so last week I tried half a dozen and accuracy is back and the keyholes have stopped. BUT, the paper patch still tumbled so I removed the wrapping, did my manual knurl job and then new paper wrap. Yesterday I tried several with an OD of 0.448 (with paper patch in place) and no tumbling? I looked and did not find anything about knurling paper patched bullets so I thought I would speak up.
I am going to cast a bunch of new bullets of both grease groove and smooth sided with as near to pure lead as I can get as my current batch has some lino mixed in but the ingots were made several years ago and I don't remember the actual ratios? Does anyone have any thoughts on this issue or has done this? Thank you.