The solution appears too easy to me, just use the same heavy-handed ations that were taken when Larry Gibson was banned from posting in this entire sub-forum... Actually, I don't think it's necessary to even go that far... How about taking just that one thread, as proposed originally, and give the oppressed testers a safe place to post their results and voice their OPINIONS without fear of "moderator intervention".
The only people you'd need to restrict from posting there, to keep the thread on track without the bickering (which we all desire), appears to be any of "The Three Amigos" and 45 2.1.
There is no reason that these results and opinions of all the aftermarket, slow-twist testers shouldn't be archived here, the same as the info being presented in your HV thread continues without interruption.
These members DESERVE the same latitude. It's only fair.