I have been trying this out. Richard Lee says his TL boolits often shoot better without sizing. (probably won't apply to any GC boolit)
Today I seated some TL-358-158 SWCs over a prudent amount of Unique and fired them through my Blackhawk, and also through my 357 Maximum H&R 1871. In the Blackhawk, they seemed about the same, but in the rifle, 5 shots went into 2 holes, a half inch apart; one hole was 2 boolits, the other hole was 3 !
I have heard rumors that shooting the shorter magnum case in the longer maximum chamber will degrade performance, but I think that's not the case here !