You think those other loads are powder puff. I run 4.0gn TG with a 230gn Hornady HAP for IDPA SSP. Comes in right about 600 FPS and recoils lighter than a 9mm.
Yes I get the soot mark on the brass, but a little Lemi Shine/dish soap bath in the kitchen sink followed by about 30 minutes in the tumbler and they look like new again.