Kinda a generalized statement I know. I find that shooting my auto's generally to be a very fun and capable platform. To be honest ... if I could retrieve all or at least most of my brass ... this would be a total no-brainer.
I find that in a long range proposition ... the hands down favorite would be the revolver with a very fine trigger and 6 to 8 inch barrel combined with a generally good long range chambering. Hunting and small game is very high in my opinion. I like the deliberate mode of fire a revolver gives and while the auto works very well in this department (hunting) I hate with a vengence having to search around for brass. Generally the revolvers have taller sights for shooting at various ranges with precision. The revolver also has for me a better grip options for rubber recoil absorbing comfort so shooting hotter and heavier boolits in general hunting rounds. I am fond of revolvers in the guise of from cap-n-ball up through modern double action. I have a very much higher round count with revolvers ... BUT ...
Auto's are sooo fun. As long as I find myself in a shooting area with a paved or cement floor and sometimes a wall for the empty's to be corralled in ... then I find relaxing and fun as well as accurate shooting is a great time. HOWEVER ... if I go afield in search of table fair ... confidence is disturbed what with the certain knowledge that brass will be lost ... and for me leastwise ... I run on the ragged edge of being a poor boy ... continual purchase of brass seems very defeating to this shooter that reloads ALL my firearms to be enabled to shoot as much as I can without certain knowledge that while out walkin round ... every shot out there gets expensive with near total loss of brass. I really like the grip and general gentle recoil that does not detract from obtaining very fine accuracy with seemingly not a bunch of repeat practice. The grip frames generally feel perfect to me with an ergonomics that just fits. Then there is the possible confrontation with a group of bad guys [ oops PEOPLE] . The confidence in large capacity auto's is indeed a comfortable feeling. I have lived in and around tougher neighborhoods where the auto found its way on my person a lot of times.
Sooo ... that is my initial feelings and impressions of the subject. There is lots more points to be made ... but ... this is a start of a discussion on this subject.
Lotsa emotional points to be made but I think that I would like to hear others opinions on the old " REVOLVER V PISTOL " reasoning and stands. I would like to discover more options to the brass loss with auto's. Truely if I did not dread losing brass ... my auto's would find their way with me on woods walks.