PBcastcoRotoMetals2WidenersLoad Data
Titan ReloadingReloading EverythingLee PrecisionRepackbox
Inline Fabrication MidSouth Shooters Supply
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 32

Thread: Soft or Hard Alloy for a .45-70

  1. #1
    Boolit Grand Master


    GregLaROCHE's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Location
    Southern France by way of Interior Bush Alaska
    Posts
    5,286

    Soft or Hard Alloy for a .45-70

    For hunting with a .45-70, is a soft alloy that opens up better than a hard one that goes right through? Maybe the answer is in what you’re hunting. What about with hollow points? Harder or softer alloy?

  2. #2
    Boolit Buddy Static line's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Northeast Ohio
    Posts
    277
    I am using a NOE 350 gr. WFN bullet for deer in my 45-70 cast from 100% coww with bhn between 16 and 19. It leaves a nice 1/2 inch hole clear through so expansion is surely something that is not needed.My cousin used one of the Hornady 325 gr. gummy tip bullets this year in his 45-70 and boy what a mess.I took more edible meat home from the processors. I absolutely hate any type of HP for deer,varmints,ok but deer,no.That's just my opinion,of course but some do like them.

  3. #3
    Boolit Master dh2's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Ft.Bragg,NC
    Posts
    707
    I have had different experience than Static line , I started casting RCBS 458-405 FP out of #2 Lyman alloy , it would kill deer and pigs but never expanded so only the 1/2 inch wound channel and accuracy a lot less than my rifle was capable of.
    I ended up through learning going to a NOE 460-405 HP cast form about 40 to 1 pure lead to tin out 8 to 10 Bhn. this has been giving me a bout a inch exit hole with lots of blood lose and the animal dropping faster , most of the time planted where he was hit.

  4. #4
    Boolit Buddy
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Location
    Alberta, Canada
    Posts
    158
    Personally I would tend to pick as soft a bullet as possible for hunting with the 45-70.
    The exceptions would be if I really needed velocity or penetration. If I needed velocity I would pick a different chambering.

    The half inch hole straight through is probably going to work fine but I would rather dump as much energy as possible into the animal and no cast bullets from a 45-70 are likely going to have explosive effects at the speeds attainable. Wouldn't bother with hollow points either though. Too much trouble to cast in my opinion (especially since I would have to start by buying the mold).

  5. #5
    Boolit Master dh2's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Location
    Ft.Bragg,NC
    Posts
    707
    Quote Originally Posted by vagrantviking View Post
    Personally I would tend to pick as soft a bullet as possible for hunting with the 45-70.
    The exceptions would be if I really needed velocity or penetration. If I needed velocity I would pick a different chambering.

    The half inch hole straight through is probably going to work fine but I would rather dump as much energy as possible into the animal and no cast bullets from a 45-70 are likely going to have explosive effects at the speeds attainable. Wouldn't bother with hollow points either though. Too much trouble to cast in my opinion (especially since I would have to start by buying the mold).

    I have to agree with you I think my accuracy improved from going to a bollit size .460 and now I don't believe the HP does much in this case, but now I own the mold. the 45/70 have had enough energy to go through every thing it shot regardless of angle or distance over 100 yards,

  6. #6
    Banned
    Join Date
    Dec 2018
    Posts
    3,409
    I'm having a problem with "100% coww with bhn between 16 and 19" unless it's quenched I've never seen coww over 12.
    I like the softest lead that will shoot accurately and mushroom on impact.
    Popper is working on a new way to harden just the base - drive bands of a lead boolit. I'm watching to see what he comes up with.

  7. #7
    Boolit Master
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Location
    Deary, Ideeeeeeho
    Posts
    2,392
    Greg,

    All you need is a good Wide Flat Nose bullet of at least 400gr and pushed somewhere in the mid 1000 - 2000fps range and it will flat get er done!

    In my 45/70, I use a 50/50 alloy of Clip On Wheel weights/lead and water quench the bullets as they fall from the mold.

    Have taken a pile of deer and three elk with that bullet with a velocity of right at 1650fps. If it expands, OK so be it , but with the WFN/large meplat I could really care less about expansion.

    Every deer with only one exception has dropped where it stood and the elk were down in less time then it takes to tell about it.

    During the 2017 deer season I took two deer with my RUGER 77/44 using a WFN 275/280gr at 1750fps and both dropped where they stood with complete pass through.

    The .44 bullets were cast of clip on wheel weights and water quenched.

    If expansion happens, so be it, but the large meplat of the Wide Flat Nose gets er done!

    Crusty Deary Ol'Coot

  8. #8
    Boolit Buddy Static line's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Northeast Ohio
    Posts
    277
    Quote Originally Posted by Conditor22 View Post
    I'm having a problem with "100% coww with bhn between 16 and 19" unless it's quenched I've never seen coww over 12.
    I like the softest lead that will shoot accurately and mushroom on impact.
    Popper is working on a new way to harden just the base - drive bands of a lead boolit. I'm watching to see what he comes up with.
    Mostly my bhn readings with the 100 % coww are 16 and 17 bhn after a long cure but those were air cooled on winter cold days,probably not much different then water quenching on a summer day.I just got done casting on a couple 40 degree days here,outside,and they dropped at 10 and 11 bhn. I'm thinking they might make it to 16 bhn after a cure time too.We'll see.

  9. #9
    Boolit Grand Master


    GregLaROCHE's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2018
    Location
    Southern France by way of Interior Bush Alaska
    Posts
    5,286
    Would you use the same BHN for wild hogs as deer?

  10. #10
    Boolit Master
    Join Date
    Jul 2013
    Location
    barry s wales uk
    Posts
    2,655
    I look at 45 boolits as pre expanded.

  11. #11
    Boolit Master

    Join Date
    Apr 2012
    Location
    State of Denial
    Posts
    4,192
    Truly a topic of great philosophical debate!

    The thing about harder alloys - they will often shoot more accurately, at least when you start ramping up the velocities. A gas check design for the softer alloys will help you out in that department.

    A flat nose .45 rifle slug that does not expand is going to keep travelling in a straight line through whatever critter bits get in its way, and crush a 1/2" to 3/4" hole in the process. The notion here is that the clean kill is more down to marksmanship than "special effects": you draw a line through a vital organ, successfully send a bullet along that line, and let the fatal bleed-out commence. Do it right, your deer is down in ten seconds.

    More diameter in theory equals a faster bleed out, but if the bullet stops in the animal, you lose wound channel DEPTH. Wound VOLUME is a matter of both length AND depth, so wider all by itself is not necessarily a special thing. It DOES however, have the potential to blow up a whole lot of perfectly good meat.

    Bullets kill through one of two mechanisms - blood loss or nerve system destruction. Magic is not on the table. Unless you scramble the brains or sever the spine, the instantaneous Hollywood "bang-flop" is pure chance. A half-inch hole through the cardiovascular system will kill anything in short order, but be ready to search the surrounding 50-ish yards.

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	.32-20 9 and 3 jugs 1250fps.jpg 
Views:	1397 
Size:	5.1 KB 
ID:	233354

    Two 130 grain WFN .32 bullets cast from the same mold - one of water-quenched wheelweights and the other of 20-1 lead/tin shot into rows of milk jugs from about 15 feet at 1250 fps. The hard bullet took nine jugs to stop and the nose only compressed slightly, the soft bullet stopped in three - which is about on par with what you'll see from police duty pistol loads.

    Click image for larger version. 

Name:	20150210_160441 (1).jpg 
Views:	51 
Size:	35.4 KB 
ID:	233355

    More of the same with 20-1 in a 180 grain WFN from a 38-.40 rifle. As I recall, about 1400 fps and took four jugs to stop.

    No pics, but I got nine jugs out of a similar shape, hard-alloy 230 grain .45 ACP at standard GI hardball speed of 830fps. No, it wouldn't be my first choice, but if I were hungry enough, I'd have ZERO qualms about sneaking to bayonet range to use that load on an elk.

    Another facet of expansion is that it can be very velocity-dependent. You're looking to hit your animal in that Goldilocks zone of not too fast (potential bullet explosion) and not too slow (no deformation), and hoping the animal cooperates by appearing at the right range. In contrast, the hard, flat-nosed bullet will leave an almost identical wound track at any distance. Consistency and lack of mystery - it ain't a bad thing, and I prefer penetration over expansion for that reason.

    On a deer, all of the above ammo would work just fine on broadside shots. Different angles or larger animals (i.e. Cape buffalo) would tip the scales in favor of straight line penetration. One African professional's goal is to draw a line through the animal to the shoulder on the opposite side of the body. That will not only poke a hole through the pumphouse, but will take out a fourth of the animal's support structure. You might lose some shoulder meat, but if the alternative is losing the animal (maybe a potentially dangerous one) in thick cover or having it run down a ravine or into a swamp, it's a good call. That method kills them AND anchors them.

    Now, I don't think I could bring enough jugs to the range in one trip to stop 405 grains of hard-cast .45-70 at Marlin or Ruger #1 speeds. Even with expansion, there's little in North America that would present a penetration challenge to that much mass. I would NOT pick a hollow point, but something that gradually squishes out to .70-.80 cal would be just fine with me for medium, non-dangerous stuff - - provided it still groups well. Worst case - it's still a "pre-expanded" .45.
    WWJMBD?

    In the Land of Oz, we cast with wheel weight and 2% Tin, Man.

  12. #12
    Boolit Grand Master

    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Location
    Northwest Ohio
    Posts
    14,420
    A bullet that will expand dumps more energy into the given target, than a solid. To me Ideally the perfect performance would be an exit hole and pocking the bullet up off of the ground within 5-10 feet of the animal. 99.5% energy dump into the animal with just enough left to leave an exit hole. Accuracy and placement of the shot is more important than anything. Energy expended after its left the animal is energy wasted on a hillside tree or air. Its the energy dumped in the animal that does the work. A deer or hog (150-300lb animal) hit right and a good energy dump is done.

  13. #13
    Boolit Master
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Location
    Deary, Ideeeeeeho
    Posts
    2,392
    Greg,

    With my 45/70, I'd use the same bullet and same hardness for ANY and ALL game hunted in North American and most of the rest of the world besides. That is a 465gr Wide Flat Nose cast of 50/50 - Clip on Wheel Weights and lead, water quenched as they fall from the mold. With proper shot placement, preferred is behind the shoulders if given a side to side shot, it just simply works.

    Not sure I can agree with BigSlug as I have only had one deer run from the spot where it stood at the shot when using the 45/70. That included a 100yd. deer taken with a side to side behind the shoulders shot and a 280gr WFN .44 taken during the 2017 season.

    With the one that ran when hit with the 45/70 slug, it was my fault for hitting the critter just a touch too far back, more in the diaphragm/liver area. Dead on it's feet, but ran 50+ yards.

    For whatever reason, I can no longer attached photographs to this forum, or I'd show the one and likely only bullet I'll ever find in a critter shot with the 45/70.

    Found one, that being from the first cow elk I took, a quartering shot at about 100yds which took out the BIG heavy front leg bone, a rib, through the lungs, through the paunch and guts stopping just under the hide right in front of the off side ham. Velocity 1650fps+/- the 50/50 cast bullet, starting weight 465gr and the "after" weight 327.9gr, the bullet continuing about 30" after taking out that heavy bone and I suspect loosing it's nose. The critter down in seconds. Same with the other two elk I've brought home with side to side behind the shoulder hits and complete pass through, range 100 to 161yds.

    The 50/50 water quenched alloy has been used at the recommendation of the mold maker and it has been very successful on both the deer and the elk.

    As per your question about deer or hogs, I go back to my earlier statement. I'd use the same bullet and load for any North American critter I might have the privilege to hunt from the smallest deer to the largest bear.

    By the way, the deer I took in 2017 with the RUGER 77/44 with a behind the shoulder shot was one of two deer that rifle and bullet/load (1750fps+/-) accounted for during that season. The second, much closer then the first was taken with a neck shot and of course it dropped where it stood. Again a complete pass through the neck a shoulder blade and exited at the back of the shoulder. Bullet cast of just plain old clip on wheel weights. water quenched as they fell from the mold.

    I'm one that seeks to optimize ONE load/bullet for any given hunting rifle I have/use and there is simply NO reason to be switching loads, bullets, or hardness depending on the critter when hunting with the 45/70.

    As robg said, consider the .45 slug to be "pre-expanded". Use a good Wide Flat Nose/large meplat bullet from a reasonable alloy and leave the worry at home. With proper shot placement and mid 1000 - 2000fps velocity it WILL get er done! One bullet, one load for everything.

    Crusty Deary Ol'Coot

  14. #14
    Boolit Master
    Join Date
    Apr 2006
    Location
    Central Virginia
    Posts
    4,707
    Only thing I've killed with a 45-70 were deer . Got a big bodied 6 pointer 10 or 11 years ago using the Gould HP bullet in a Marlin 1895CB with a tang sight . Killed a few more with variouse Marlin 45-70's shooting Ranch Dog 350 and 425 grain gas check FP bullets . ALL were cast with straight WW's and air cooled . None went further then 30 yards after the shot . Incidently the one I killed with the Gould bullet was BOOM FLOP !
    Parker's , 6.5mm's and my family in the Philippines

  15. #15
    Boolit Buddy
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    CT
    Posts
    109
    So what would you use for hunting moose and buffalo, hard or soft alloy?

  16. #16
    Boolit Master knifemaker's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Mountain area of Northern CA.
    Posts
    927
    I have killed several buffalo with a Ranch Dog 350 gr. boolit that was cast from clip on wheel weights with 2% tin added for mold fillout. Both buffalo were one shot kills and no tracking involved. Recovered only one of the boolits and it had expanded to about 75 caliber after going though the shoulders. Was found under hide on far shoulder. I size to .460 and this boolit will give me 1 inch groups of 3 shots at 100 yards. Velocity is close to 1900 fps out of my Marlin 1895 rifle.

  17. #17
    Boolit Grand Master

    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Location
    NW GA
    Posts
    7,243
    If you make them too hard, they get brittle. Take some linotype and see how it compares to ACWW or ACWW/Soft lead. I use wither ACWW or ACWW/Soft lead (COWW) in equal proportions. Water quenching makes the boolit harder but not necessarily brittle like linotype. Any WFN driven at moderate velocity will get the job done in a 45/70 or .40"+ Magnum round. Shot placement, as always, is important.

  18. #18
    Boolit Master
    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Location
    Moorhead, MN
    Posts
    688
    Will you shoot your game in the shoulder or tight behind it?

  19. #19
    Boolit Grand Master
    white eagle's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    718 miles E. of Wall Drug
    Posts
    6,149
    with a 45-70 there is no need to expand
    use a good boolit with a decent meplat and your golden
    Hit em'hard
    hit em'often

  20. #20
    DOR RED BEAR's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Location
    1 mile from chickahominy river ( swamp) central va
    Posts
    2,162
    I don't think it matters much. I would think that a 45/70 with a well placed shot should drop a deer in short order. If you do your job it should certainly do its.

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Abbreviations used in Reloading

BP Bronze Point IMR Improved Military Rifle PTD Pointed
BR Bench Rest M Magnum RN Round Nose
BT Boat Tail PL Power-Lokt SP Soft Point
C Compressed Charge PR Primer SPCL Soft Point "Core-Lokt"
HP Hollow Point PSPCL Pointed Soft Point "Core Lokt" C.O.L. Cartridge Overall Length
PSP Pointed Soft Point Spz Spitzer Point SBT Spitzer Boat Tail
LRN Lead Round Nose LWC Lead Wad Cutter LSWC Lead Semi Wad Cutter
GC Gas Check