Which one?

[SSGOldfart]

Thomas My vote would be to send the per 64. It fits better into the 38-55 time period.

[HawkCreek]

I didn't read 454 article but was that a 336 or 1894 Marlin? The 1894 is a different animal. A 336
is same action they use on 375Win and I don't see it failing on 454.

It was a 336, the action went out the fastest (followed closely by a Winchester Big Bore 94AE). An old pre-war Winchester 94 actually lasted the longest but still failed before 50 rounds.
If you go to Winchester's website you'll see they no longer make the BigBore but they do offer the 94 in .450 Marlin.

Even so the Marlins are more accurate in most cases. In this case, the 36G has several sub moa groups to show and the 94's personal best is 2-3/4" once. At 100 yds.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

I edited the quote poorly, my fault. Wasn't meaning to argue accuracy, only strength. I never benched a lever gun (other than my '95 Winchesters).


For those interested here is the text of the tests I am referring to:
http://castboolits.gunloads.com/show...un-test-Part-1

[Drm50]

I'm going to look up the article and read it. I am curious as to what failed. I have benched dozens
of lever guns. Speaking only on traditional levers of Win & Marlin, with and without scopes the
Marlins out shoot the Wins. I would also note this would be 30/30-32 Win & 375Win. and 30/30s
for the biggest part of my experience with reciver sights shot at 60yds. I have a original 1895 Win
in 30/06 with reciver sights that will shoot with most stock 30/06s. As long as you load 160-180 gr
RN bullets. It won't shoot a spitzer bullet worth a hoot.

[Texas by God]

If you want to know when your 94 barrel was manufactured; look here!

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

[Prodigal Son]

Do the Marlin you can thank me later!

[Texas by God]

Do the Marlin you can thank me later!

I've seen your targets! I like it.

[Chad5005]

id choose the marlin for the simple fact of it being a better rifle

[indian joe]

id choose the marlin for the simple fact of it being a better rifle

I chose it for the opposite reason - its just a marlin - the pre 64 Winchester is a much nicer gun to keep intact

[Prodigal Son]

Thanks Texas by God!

[fordwannabe]

Ok here goes. If the Marlin is already shooting good dont screw with it. If the Winchester isn’t shooting good groups anyway...why not try it? I have a JES Marlin n in 35/30 groups great. I also have a post 64 JES rebored Winchester in 38/55 win win either way.

[bob208]

if they both shoot well leave them alone. look for a angle eject in .375 or a post 64 with a bad bore.

[beemer]

My hair is falling out now, couldn't make that decision. Find another rifle perhaps?

[bob208]

I said the .375 angle eject because after you get either one done the next post will be how hot can I load .38-55.

[Texas by God]

My decision came down to accuracy. I have 3 30-30s and the 94 is the least accurate by far. It's also a delight to carry and handles great. It will be great as a 38-55, too. The Marlin gets the 5D Williams and I'll try to find a period Lyman or Redfield for my 38-55. Thank you all for your opinions.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

[Texas by God]

I said the .375 angle eject because after you get either one done the next post will be how hot can I load .38-55.

No it won't. Checkered steel butt plate says so.

[Texas by God]

I sent it NW yesterday. I got a Lee mould last week and ordered brass today. I got Redding dies from our S&S forum so I'm excited!

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

[Ramjet-SS]

I am looking forward to the rest of the journey on this project it's fun to follow.

[fordwannabe]

Jesse will tell you he recommends a .376 or .377 cast bullet. MY RIFLE and my rifle only shoots much better at a .379. Just sayin. Have fun and just to get started so you can shoot it because we all know you want to shoot it as soon as you get it. 10 grains of Unique is a good basic load. Then try all kinds of other stuff

[TNsailorman]

Hey Texas, I a very interested in your project as I have been toying with the idea of converting a 336 to 38-55 or 35-30 for some time. I personally would go with the least accurate rifle. Keep us informed on your progress please. James

[Texas by God]

I'm thinking of braving the heat and skeeters tonight to break in my new .379-250 Lee mould! It wouldn't hurt to have all components ready for my 94's return.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk