Yes, I have read many threads about 9mm case trimming and the consensus from most reloaders is that they do not trim pistol caliber cases.
But........,
Since the 9mm case headspaces from the case mouth, the way I see it is for a batch of untrimmed 9mm cases that have been reloaded to a certain C.O.A.L, the length of the bullet from the case mouth will vary due to the different case lengths.
If we are trying to use a cast boolit then we set the boolit depth deeper, step by step, until it passes the 'Plunk Test".
But, since the cases vary in length, the next round set at that C.O.A.L. may not pass the plunk test due to a shorter case that was loaded and set to the desired C.O.A.L.. This would be because there is more boolit sticking out of the case and thus hitting the "rifling" in the barrel.
To avoid this potential problem trimming the 9mm cases to the same case length would solve this potential problem.
Does this make sense?...or, where am I going wrong with this thinking?