I don't have bad luck w/ broadheads. Red dots on crossbows that won't hold zero are another story. Thankfully I didn't wound any deer because of that horrible optic.
W/ parts that move it's not a matter of if they will break. It's a matter of when they will break. I don't like taking that chance when hunting. Everyone is entitled to use whatever they want as long as it's legal in your state. I just prefer simplicity w/ a lot of things in life. Guess it comes from my trade but the more complicated the equipment is the more it fails.