This could be a wild guess but are there any chances that when you’re wipe testing your baked bullets that there is some coating on your fingers? Or any dirt/soot from fluxing and casting?
I’ve splashed coating on my fingers and or had dirty hands from general lead handling and when I wipe tested I briefly mistakened the mess on the paper towel as unbaked coating. Since then I make sure that a hold a bullet in tongs or hold longer bullets by one end, making sure not to contact my fingers to the paper towel.
As stated above. Over baked and under cured do not happen together.