I am almost certain it is zinc contamination from some mystery ingots I melted and repoured since they were varying hardnesses. The oatmeal look just did not sound like my gold tinged crystalline sludge. My little Hot Pot II does not get hot enough to realy melt zinc I believe. As I poured ingots and the lead level lowered, a silver gold crystalline sludge started to form. I did this after I ended up with 3 golden ingots that were very hard, but after those it never seemed liquid enough once I poured the cleaned lead(?) out . I also noticed high surface tension on the melt.