What vintage reloading manual do you find to be the most useful or best reference?
Printable View
What vintage reloading manual do you find to be the most useful or best reference?
Lyman #44 Gp
I’ve also had the mindset that ya can’t have to many reloading manuals. They all have there place. If I had to pick on that won’t brake the bank and is pretty easy to find Lyman cast bullet #3 has a lot of good info. A lot depends on what your reloading for.
Lyman #45
A lot of the Lyman 44th loads seem kind of warm to me. (The 44th was the first load book i ever bought.) Mostly, I start with a Pacific Handbook, but I often to to Water’s Pet Loads If it’s a brand-new cartridge I’m unfamiliar with.
Love Ken Waters Pet Loads.
Complete Guide to Handloading by Philip B. Sharpe is a classic and full of great information. Its a great resource for older cartridges not found in newer manuals. The first edition dates to 1937. I have a 3rd edition, 2nd revision from 1953.
Speer Manual for Reloading Ammunition Number 8 (1970)
Speer Reloading Manual Number Nine (1974)
Lyman Cast Bullet Handbook Third Edition (1980)
RCBS Cast Bullet Manual number 1 (1986)
Sixgun Cartridges & Loads by Elmer Keith (1936) more for general info than reloading data per se .
These are the "vintage" manuals I still use ...along with up to date Hornady , Speer and Lyman Cast Bullet Handbook #4 .
The vintage books came in handy when I discovered two full cans of Alcan #5 squirreled away during the 2013 powder shortage...find data for Alcan #5 in a new manual ...ain't happening !
Those vintage manuals came in real handy .
Gary
Depends on what brand bullets or powder you’re loading for. I use a lot of Hornady bullets and have the full collection of manuals. Have to go back the first few for some older powders. I tend to look at older Lymans quite often. Same thing w/ old manuals from powder manufacturers. Have a lot of Winchester and Hercules manuals. Same thing for VV. I collect as many as possible. Which reminds me I need to go through and check for 2020 updates.
All old manuals are used for comparison. Modern pressure testing techniques are a lot more precise. I trust the loads in newer manuals a lot more. But I always check multiple manuals as a sanity check.
Just picked up a Hodgdon #26 used at my lgs. Had s Speer manual from about 1995 and also a Sierra from a few years later but those went to my eldest. This #26 is pretty good.