Originally Posted by
dverna
As touched on, back in the days, there was no government programs to assist those in need. The "church" took on these duties or the goodness of family and friends.
I currently give what I believe to be right in my circumstances...it is not 10% and likely will never be.
Also, I agree that providing services should not be discounted as "worthless" in terms of giving. If those who are able and willing to help did not provide their talents and energy to their church, someone would need to be paid to perform those duties.
I would swiftly leave any church that expected a certain amount of giving. The church is not God and never will be.
BTW, a few weeks ago one of the churches I attend (I live in two cities) asked for an outpouring of generosity to fund "needed" capital expansions. The church is never more than 50% full. I questioned this with my fiancé and was put down for my thoughts. I let it go. But my wallet and check book remain closed. Now, that church does many good works for the community and we do support them over and above the weekly giving.