1903 rebuild verification and value questions.... pic heavy. 1903 experts?

Let me start of by saying... this is not a forsale thread!

I have had this old 1903 for 20 + years and I finally decided to figure out what I could about it. It is a beautiful gun to start with, I am not sure it was ever issued after a rebuild. I would really like to have an idea of value and may at some point consider selling it as I do not shoot it, it is way to clean and beautiful. I hate having a gun, even one this historic taking up safe space, when I do not use it. I have another one that was sporterized, I think in the 50's, that is perfectly built with awesome peep sights that I do shoot regularly.

Attachment 267902Attachment 267903Attachment 267904

I believe that it was built in 1911, based on serial number. Yes, that is one of the brittle years. It does have a Hatcher hole. I do not have the cleaning kit for this rifle.

Attachment 267905Attachment 267906

I also believe that it was arsenal rebuilt in 1942 at the San Antonio Arsenal. The stock stamps, bolt steel numbers and barrel date all indicate this is the case. The barrel is super clean and smooth and is a 4 groove without star gauge marks. The sight is an open blade with stampings as well. The blade is marked with a "0" and the blade holder is marked with an "R".

Attachment 267907Attachment 267908Attachment 267909Attachment 267911Attachment 267914

I have also found the other following stampings for proofing and manufacturer of parts used. Also, all stampings are under the original finish as should be. The butt plate is a smooth, large hole with the script "2" by the attachment screw.

Attachment 267910Attachment 267912Attachment 267913

I think, from what I have seen that this rifle should be worth somewhere around $1200 as she sits. Am I in the correct ballpark??? I can take other pics if needed.

Thanks Matt

I think that is the correct value.

Thanks, that is what I think I am seeing for similar rifles... I just know that this one is a beauty and I just can't bring myself to shoot it more than 8 or 10 reduced cast loads every 10 years or so.

That is most probably a WW II rebuild. It has a May 1942 barrel, it also has a 03A3 trigger guard/floorplate, a Remington front sight, etc.. I think you might have to run down some 1903 parts to correct that rifle to get $1200.00 for it, especially from a collector. You can find a lot of info if you can find a copy of Brophy's book of the 1903, 1903A3 and transitional models. Serial numbers, reworked number, etc.. james

According to "Hatcher's Notebook", pg. 219, this rifle is one of the late Low Number Springfields, as the improved heat treatment started with serial no. 285507 at Rock Island Arsenal. I know that you know this information, mattw, just posting it for other readers. Despite that fact, I think the estimated value will hold up, as it remains a collector item in fine condition, and U.S. Military collectables bring a premium now days, especially M1903s and 1917s.

IMO, it's not worth anywhere near $1200 in its current state. Definitely a mixmaster with a multitude of incorrect parts- and anybody's guess if it was refurbed at a gov't arsenal during WWII (my guess is not). Just as likely to have been assembled from Army surplus bits in someone's basement 30-40 years ago. (Looks exactly like one I did that way back in the mid-70's from around $50 worth of parts I accumulated.)

Sorry to sound so harsh, but even in the world of '03 Springfields there must be a high degree of "deniable plausibility" to eke top dollar out of one as being a genuine "Arsenal rework". It's value lies as a shooter, and even that's suspect due to its low serial number. Realistically, again in my opinion, $5-700. $1200 these days will still get you an honest-to-God correct '03.

At most Gun shows here on the east coast. There are between 100-300 Springfields on a variety of tables. major shows. allentown PA, Baltimore, richmond and other. Unless it's Perfect pre WWI or One cut for Peterson . Price 5-$700 is good. When you bring it to show. you learn to Wake up and smell the Coffee

The barrel, stock, trigger guard and bolt are replacements. Who did it is open to conjecture, since the barrel date would indicate mid WWII, about the same time the they were transitioning to the A3. It is possible that A3 parts may have been available but you would have to have some documentation that Remington or Smith-Corona were supplying replacement parts in excess of their requirements to rebuild sites. The bolt was made under separate contract, there were several companies doing this. Suggest you ask on the CMP forum, there are members there who are well versed in the 03. Agree that $1200 is optimistic as far as value.

Earlier this week, I saw a similar '03 that had been 'restored' sometime in its history - reblued, refinished wood, and some replaced hardware - tagged with an asking price of $2000. Of course, this was the same 'upscale' gunshop/indoor range that was asking $800 for a used 6" S&W 686-3...

Bill

If you go on Gunbroker ones like that go for $1,200, but that site is a completely different world.

What it's "worth" and what it will/can sell for are two different figures in the world of firearms today. The number of the older milsurps in original configuration (not to be confused with new "as issued" condition) is finite. The country's population has almost trippled in population in my lifetime. Thus the demand is much higher for those few finite number of such rifles. Throw in that anything old is "collectable" and that also influences the selling price above the "worth" price.

Bottom line; what the rifle is worth has nothing to do with what it can sell for.

I believe the curved bolt is a stronger bolt, according to the CMP booklet. CMP matches still won’t allow these in the Matches. I would have no issue shooting it especially with cast bullet loads.

And then you have the CMP, Mitchell’s Mausers, Shuffs Refinishing, Fords and Turnbulls rebuilding milsurps and collectibles. Collectors/shooters with deep pockets are buying those very prettied up pieces of firearm history. In 50-75 years when they age the water will become even muddier as to what something is truly worth. I hope whoever eventually gets my milsurp collection enjoys them as I have.