PDA

View Full Version : Oversize chamber



megasupermagnum
06-20-2019, 03:22 PM
I am trying to build a .410 shotgun, rifled slug gun using brass shells. To do this I am using 9.3x74R brass. I plan to trim to 2.5", and fire form. There is a number of sources on how to do this, however, my question pertains to the chamber.

I intend to shoot these hard, up to full power 45,000 psi levels. I plan to have a chamber reamer made, but it needs to be able to safely chamber and fire a .410 plastic shotgun shell to remain what is considered a shotgun by the DNR.

I'll post below what a Federal .410 plastic shotgun (labeld .410 shotgun) shell measures, followed by a 9.3x74R (labeled .410) sized approximately what it would measure for my purposes. My main concern is the case web, which measures .473" on a .410 plastic shell, and .463" on the 9.3x74R brass.

Now this will be built on a bolt action, and I do not ever intend on shooting plastic shells out of it besides just to test fire, or prove that it is a .410 shotgun to a DNR officer. Can I get away with a chamber that is .474" at the opening? If so, will .011" oversize cause any safety problems with 9.3x74R brass?

243880

243881

Moleman-
06-20-2019, 03:47 PM
The base will take a pretty decent load to fireform up near the base, and around 1/8" in front of the rim will likely stay pretty close to what it is now. As long as you're sizing to .473" dia and not the smaller .463" every time the brass shouldn't be overworked. What action are you using?

megasupermagnum
06-20-2019, 06:38 PM
As long as I can get away with it, I only intend to neck size just enough for the bullet using a .450" 44 magnum sizer. I would probably size no more than 1/2" down at the most. I will be using a Savage 110 action for this, and be using a 44 caliber barrel blank.

Here is another question for you. When trimmed to 2.5", just a small section of the original neck remains. 9.3x74R is meant for a .366" bullet. Would it be better to size down just a little bit and use a .357 bullet, or would it be better to expand and fit a 44 caliber bullet in there for fireforming. I believe I can make both ways work. I expanded one today, first with a tapered expander, then with a NOE .429" expander plug.

A third question. I am using brand new Hornady brass, that is presumably annealed. Should I anneal these again, or can I get away without it?

EDG
06-20-2019, 10:49 PM
Have you ever fired a real .410 rifled slug load?
If you stick with the original rifled slug design they are a joke. I shot an armadillo at about 20 feet with one and the slug did not exit the armadillo. After the buzzards got through a week later the armadillo shell had the slug still laying in it mashed out to the diameter of a quarter.

megasupermagnum
06-20-2019, 11:09 PM
Sure, my great uncle used to hunt deer with an old ward western bolt action .410. He hunted about 30 years with it with nothing but good results on our northern whitetail bucks until he lost his hand in a work accident.

I've never tried them on deer myself, although I have shot .410 slugs. Shooting water jugs, I didn't see much difference between them and a 357 magnum.

That's not all that related though, as what I am doing will be on par with a 444 marlin. I'm looking to shoot 300-350 grain bullets at about 2000 FPS.

Moleman-
06-21-2019, 12:04 AM
If it were me, I'd start by annealing the case neck. Then expand with a well tapered and lubed .427" expander as deep as you can go until the case starts bulging excessively because of the case wall thickness. Run back through a sizer and trim to length on the long side. The cases will shrink in length a little as the cases expand. The more they have to expand the more shrinkage there will be. I do a similar thing for several wildcat cartridges including 30-06 cases to make a 44x1.8" which will launch a 265gr interlock at over 2300fps out of a 16" barrel. The only area that really fireforms is the area above the case head as it is usually the only area undersized before firing and takes a decent load to expand.

megasupermagnum
06-21-2019, 12:40 AM
Ok, that sounds like a good plan Moleman. How much longer should the chamber be than the brass?

Moleman-
06-21-2019, 02:28 AM
Are you going to headspace both off of the rim, the case mouth or one of each? 9.3x74R looks to have a .055" rim where 410 is listed at .060". Don't have any 9.3x74R to check but a box of Win super-X 3" #6 shot seems to have a rim .055"-.057" thick. If you were going to headspace it off of the rim, you'd need a lip on the chamber except on the bottom for feeding and where the extractor rotates. I would suspect that if the HS was on the tight side for 410 it would still close since the 410 rim isn't solid on most shells.

AntiqueSledMan
06-21-2019, 06:05 AM
Hello megasupermagnum,

Why not use Magtech Brass Shells?

https://www.ballisticproducts.com/MagTech-410-2-1_2-empty-brass-shotshells-for-reloading/productinfo/3924165/

I would think if a Warden would check your ammo with a 9.3x74R head stamp he would issue a citation.

AntiqueSledMan.

Wayne Smith
06-21-2019, 07:29 AM
If you go ahead with this fire form your brass with a couple layers of Scotch tape around the base, enough to just fit into the chamber. This centers the case and the fireform exists ahead of it, centering the fireformed case. Not my idea, came from reading Donnelly et al. After fireforming the case the tape can be removed as the fireformed case will be centered for all future shooting.

GhostHawk
06-21-2019, 08:29 AM
To be honest I think you are skating around the edge of the rules here.

If a gamewarden ever looked down the barrel and saw rifling where he was expecting smoothbore I suspect you'd be in trouble.

Essentially, if I am reading this right, you want to make a rifled barrel with brass case that would shoot essentially a .44mag bullet. But still be able to chamber a .410 shot shell.

I think at the least you are breaking the spirit of the law. Maybe more, maybe no. Would depend on how the law is actually written, and interpretation by the officer.


That being said, I've watched my dad take more than his share of deer with a .410 pump shotgun and slugs. Trick is you have to get close.

All that being said, its your project, you decide. But I think your riding for a fall. And felt duty bound to warn you.

AntiqueSledMan
06-21-2019, 11:08 AM
GhostHawk,

Minnesota does allow rifled barrels in the shotgun zone.
But to build a wildcat cartridge and call it a .410 shot shell
would be the question, my guess is any warden or judge
would see a rifle with a wildcat cartridge not a shotgun.

AntiqueSledMan.

megasupermagnum
06-21-2019, 11:52 AM
Yes, absolutely no law against rifled barrels here. Rifled barrel shotguns have been used since they first came out a long time ago. Believe me when I say I've done a lot of time digging through the laws about shotguns. The scary thing is the only thing the DNR books say on the matter is a "shotgun shooting single projectile". I've called 13 individuals asking for a definition of a shotgun, including the warden in my hunting area. Not a single one of them has called me back. Most didn't even answer their phone. I talked to the warden a while, and he again said "shotgun shooting single projectile". I asked specifically, can I shoot brass shells. He said no problem. I asked if there was any reason I couldn't use 444 marlin brass. That got him stumbling. I asked again, what is the MN legal definition of a shotgun, remembering that rifled barrels are allowed. He had no answer, and said he would call me back. He never did.

The point being that the Minnesota DNR does not recognize what a shotgun is. Is it a smooth bore? No, rifled barrels are allowed. Is it the plastic case? No, brass cases have been used since the dawn of time, and there is no law against them.

The only thing I am changing is I am using a 44 caliber bullet, rather than 41. I am fire forming 9.3x74r brass to a .410 shotgun. We are discussing minor differences here, but that is only because of a lack of good, reasonably priced .410 brass. I will be shooting .410 brass shells in a .410 shotgun with a rifled barrel. The only thing wild cat about it is the amount of powder I'm going to use. Spirit of the law, that's a good one! If the intention was to limit range for sporting or safety purposes, why can't we use buckshot? I'd much rather use my favorite shotgun and 000 buckshot. This project is mostly for fun.

Magtec brass is no good for a number of reasons discussed in my other thread in the special projects section.

Anyway, thanks for the tape idea for centering the brass. As for headspacing, on actual cartridges I don't see much difference for rim thickness. A plastic shotgun shell is anything but precision. I would much rather headspace for the 9.3x74r cartridge, and have it a tight fit for .410 plastic shells. Being a bolt action, I don't think it will be a problem. Savage actions have been chambered in rimmed cartridges before, so I don't think it will be a problem. A sharp edge on the barrel shank should do the trick. I already don't expect it to feed from the magazine, and will use this as a single shot.

AntiqueSledMan
06-21-2019, 08:20 PM
Hello megasupermagnum,

I had a conversation at the local gun shop today on this topic,
he claimed that the state is considering making straight wall
cases legal in shot gun zones. That would make it a lot easier.

AntiqueSledMan.

megasupermagnum
06-21-2019, 08:46 PM
Yes it would. It was up for vote this year, did not get passed. As far as I know, us and NY are the only two states who have not allowed straight wall cartridges yet. Personally I think the whole thing is ridiculous. Just allow firearms during the firearms season, don't even dink with only allowing some straight wall cartridges. The best season is muzzleloader anyway. I've always said the regular firearms deer is the 2 weeks out of the year even non-hunters come out, get drunk, and shoot deer. I'm glad they do. 2 weeks to get it out of their system, and the rest of the year is perfect for hunting. I'm just fortunate to have private land to hide on for regular firearms deer.

Anyway, that's why I'm building this rifle. It's currently legal as a shotgun. When straight wall cartridges are allowed, it will still be a top choice. For kids, it can't be beat. I believe my nephew will be using it in a couple years, and loaded to handgun levels will have no recoil. For the rest of the year, I think it would be great to shoot blackpowder for fun. This rifle checks all those boxes.

I called a gunsmith today, he says he sees no problem with it. Find a contoured barrel, bring him the reamer, and $250, done deal.

GhostHawk
06-21-2019, 09:06 PM
Well I agree with you, and I don't.

There is a difference between a rifled shotgun barrel, shooting shotgun slugs.

And a .44mag barrel designed to shoot essentially a center fire rifle. With resulting higher pressures and speeds. Which happens to be chambered to also fit a .410 shotgun in order to get around a law.

Pressures, speeds, are vastly different. Where the law is concerned I suspect your in a gray area.


But, as I said, its your project, your money, your reputation that you are putting at risk.
Only you can decide if it is worth it.

But IMO there is a big difference between a rifled shotgun barrel shooting factory or hand loaded slugs at 12-1500 fps.
And a center fire rifle that can easily enough kick that up into or above the 2400fps. To me you are violating the intent of the law. That being to limit the range that a stray bullet can travel before it hits ground, tree, or someones house.

I do agree they need to define what is a shotgun and what is and what is not allowed.

Having grown up hunting deer with shotgun and slugs in northern Minn I think I disagree with the way you are going about it. Play the game straight up, no blurring of lines, no fudging of rules. Just get sneaky, get close, and put them in the freezer and hang them on the wall.

But I could be wrong, have been before, will be again. No ill will or hard feelings intended. It is an interesting discussion and project.

GregLaROCHE
06-21-2019, 10:07 PM
Buy a .45-70 and be done with it. Unless you’re hunting in a shotgun only area and trying to slip past the regs. If so when building this gun, make sure you choose the correct rifle twist for the boolit and charge.

Good luck and let us know how it works ou.

megasupermagnum
06-21-2019, 10:08 PM
I mean no insult, but I am genuinely curious. In what way is a hot loaded .410 plastic shell ok, and a hot loaded brass shell not? Nowhere does it say you have to use plastic, or paper, or one of the other things shotgun shells have been made out of. Would it be better if I used a .410" groove barrel?

The law is gray. Unless they specify smooth bore barrels with slugs or buckshot, there is no such thing as playing it straight up.

If the intent of the law was to limit over travel of a bullet, buckshot would be legal. It is not.

Let me put it to you another way. A number of factory loaded 12 gauge sabot slugs are a 300 grain bullet at 2000 fps. The 3" Remington AccuTip is a 385 grain bullet at 1900 fps. Realistically, my .410 shotgun will be able to launch a 300 grain bullet at 2200 fps, a 350 grain at 2000 fps or so.

megasupermagnum
06-21-2019, 10:25 PM
Buy a .45-70 and be done with it. Unless you’re hunting in a shotgun only area and trying to slip past the regs. If so when building this gun, make sure you choose the correct rifle twist for the boolit and charge.

Good luck and let us know how it works ou.

Yep, shotgun only zone.

I'm looking at a Pac-Nor 44 caliber 1:18" twist. That should do the job.

17nut
06-22-2019, 01:09 PM
Why not put the buggy in front of the horse?

Why not cut the chamber to fit the 9,3 cases perfect and then have a small handfull of .410 shells that you size while loaded so they fit your chamber?

lar45
06-22-2019, 02:20 PM
A +1 on the tape around the base to center the case while fireforming.
On expanding the mouth. Just fire form it instead of using expanders. Put 5-8gns of a fast powder in the bottom of the case, cover with a piece of tissue paper packed tight, then fill with cream of wheat or grits and add another tissue plug on top tamped in tight. Then chamber and fire. It will expand the neck without any problems. I've done this with 30-30 brass to make 375Win brass and ended up with a longer case than trying to use a series of expanders. I also lost several cases trying to expand that far, but none fireforming.
Just make sure that your barrel is at least 18" long if you are calling it a shotgun. I would have the barrel marked 410 2 1/2", or similar designating it a 410 shotgun.
Should be similar to the 12ga from hell project. It uses brass cases loaded to a much higher pressure, but is still legally considered a 12ga shotgun by the ATF because it will still chamber and fire any 12ga round.

15meter
06-22-2019, 03:49 PM
And hold the rifle vertical while fire forming. Holding horizontal has the potential of lop-sided cases, couldn't believe the difference between horizontal and vertical when fire forming 38-55's from 30-30's.

It does make your yard look sort of festive from the tissue paper confetti, though.

cpaspr
06-23-2019, 01:20 AM
You mentioned that this will be built on a bolt action. That action is what, ultimately, will define what you are building. Is the action from a rifle? If so, then you are building a rifle that CAN shoot (though you admit to having no intent to do so regularly) a .410 shotshell.

Basically, it sounds like you are really trying to shoot a rifle in a shotgun only area, and if caught have a way out of the ticket.

megasupermagnum
06-23-2019, 05:28 PM
I'm building it on a Savage 110 action. Savage makes same action, slightly modified for both 20 gauge and 12 gauge. They are rifled barrel slug guns. They call them the 220 and 212. Essentially I'm building a Savage 267. The two reasons I'm not sold on a Savage 220 (20 gauge), is 1. It has no throat, and 2. I would not be able to use brass cases without buying custom from RMC brass. You could buy a bunch of the factory ammo for $5 per shot, and one of the loads is bound to shoot 2-3" at 100 yards at best. That's not worth it to me for the price they gouge people.

If a shotgun built on a bolt action is illegal or somehow immoral, then there are a LOT of people in the wrong. After that, should we drag the even more popular Thompson Center Encore "pistol" with 15" barrel chambered in 30-06, 7mm-08, or one of the many other bottle neck rifle cases. All completely legal in MN.

Thank you for the tip about the tape, and holding level when fire forming. I think I have all I need to form cases now. Or at least enough to get started and screw it up.

lar45
06-24-2019, 02:31 PM
I was going to suggest 405 Win brass as it's already about 2.5" long, but it appears that it's no longer available most places. I'm glad I bought a bunch when I got my rifle a few years back.

15meter
06-24-2019, 07:58 PM
I'm building it on a Savage 110 action. Savage makes same action, slightly modified for both 20 gauge and 12 gauge. They are rifled barrel slug guns. They call them the 220 and 212. Essentially I'm building a Savage 267. The two reasons I'm not sold on a Savage 220 (20 gauge), is 1. It has no throat, and 2. I would not be able to use brass cases without buying custom from RMC brass. You could buy a bunch of the factory ammo for $5 per shot, and one of the loads is bound to shoot 2-3" at 100 yards at best. That's not worth it to me for the price they gouge people.

If a shotgun built on a bolt action is illegal or somehow immoral, then there are a LOT of people in the wrong. After that, should we drag the even more popular Thompson Center Encore "pistol" with 15" barrel chambered in 30-06, 7mm-08, or one of the many other bottle neck rifle cases. All completely legal in MN.

Thank you for the tip about the tape, and holding level when fire forming. I think I have all I need to form cases now. Or at least enough to get started and screw it up.

I do it while holding the rifle vertical. I don't seem to get lopsided cases.

AntiqueSledMan
06-25-2019, 06:46 AM
Hello Megasupermagnum,

Please keep us posted on this project.
I had always thought of a 410 Lever with rifling cut,
should shoot about a .430 bullet with a Brass Hull.

Thanks, AntiqueSledMan.

Lionel Allen
06-26-2019, 11:50 PM
There used to be 12 bore rifles in the olden days. Read about them in the Double Gun Journal. Fully rifled SXS. I figure that so long as your gun is marked .410 Shotgun you should be good to go.

Billthomas
07-02-2019, 05:36 PM
For what its worth, I have a scratch built sharps borchardt on my bench now that went in your direction. I purchased a blank from Les Bauska in .405 Win., the bore is .412, I tried to compromise between the .410 and the.405 by rimming 06 brass and fire forming, by polishing the chamber to fit, I'm now fitting a 45-70 barrel to it and chalking it all up to experience. It fired the .410 okay but the rest wasn't worth the effort. Thanks for listening.

mjwcaster
07-07-2019, 10:16 AM
Why not put the buggy in front of the horse?

Why not cut the chamber to fit the 9,3 cases perfect and then have a small handfull of .410 shells that you size while loaded so they fit your chamber?

I would not suggest this.
I have heard of too many stories where a hunter has a plugged magazine, will only hold the correct number of rounds that the hunter is using.
But the game warden carries their special shorter rounds and uses those to check the gun.
And the warden can fit in one more round.
My buddy got lucky and only got a warning for it.

Stories usually involve a warden everyone knows the reputation of, and dislikes, even other game wardens.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk