PDA

View Full Version : I think I have a problem with diameter



nueces5
05-05-2019, 06:08 PM
Today I went to shoot the new boolits in my G17. Approximately after about 40 shots I started making keyholings.
The diameter is .3555, the slug of my glock is .355 and they are PC.
The armed bullet does not pass the plunk test satisfactorily, because if I do more crimp, I reduce its diameter. It falls well in the bedroom but does not rotate with the fingers.
Should I try to increase the diameter of my boolits? I think this week I got the expander that Lathesmith did to me, that I hope it's a help.
Or should I respect the plunk test?
Six months into this, I still can not find the way to be precise with this gun.
Inside barrel.
https://i.ibb.co/8zBS4pb/30208-DBC-6-D24-48-CB-B86-A-487-DE55-ADA3-E.jpg (https://ibb.co/YDWqTMX)
https://i.ibb.co/8zBS4pb/30208-DBC-6-D24-48-CB-B86-A-487-DE55-ADA3-E.jpg (https://ibb.co/YDWqTMX)
My boolit
https://i.ibb.co/X2cZP0G/A8-F625-C6-1-F99-4-A0-A-A5-F2-E5-A6848459-C3.jpg (https://ibb.co/YRH7SnV)

toallmy
05-05-2019, 06:25 PM
Contact a member named Doug guy , see if he can work his magic on your chamber , then you can plunk a little fatter Boolit .

waksupi
05-05-2019, 06:28 PM
I would say you need a bigger bullet. You might try shooting softer alloy, but it probably won't slug up enough to solve the problem.

toallmy
05-05-2019, 06:33 PM
Possibly reducing over all length it might help with the plunk test also , your throat might be catching on the shoulder of your cast boolits .

nueces5
05-05-2019, 07:02 PM
Contact a member named Doug guy , see if he can work his magic on your chamber , then you can plunk a little fatter Boolit .
I live in Argentina! I think I'm going to try first to broaden my boolits and reduce the OAL:p

Dieselhorses
05-05-2019, 07:09 PM
According to Hodgdon Reloading your bullet needs to be .356 and your alloy, as mentioned, should be softer. Don't know what the weight is of yours is but a 125 gr LCN OAL is 1.125" with HP-38 and TG. Also maybe it's my imagination but your loaded round looks like the either the case isn't square or the bullet didn't seat right. Just speculation.

Dave W.
05-05-2019, 07:22 PM
In my opinion you have two problems; the OAL is too long. The straight side of the bullet, just before the taper should stick out the end of the case about the thickness of your thumb nail. With the124 grain truncated boolits that I cast the OAL is 1.050.

Secondly the barrel is leading - getting fouled. There are several different things that can cause leading - fouling. Once you correct why the barrel is not staying clean, the gun will shoot accurately.

The rule of thumb is to size lead boolits .001 over the barrel diameter.

Walks
05-05-2019, 07:23 PM
Seat the bullet deeper in the case.
Use a harder alloy.
Buy a Wolf bbl with conventional rifling.

RED BEAR
05-05-2019, 07:42 PM
I would try to increase bullet size first i usually go a full .001 to .002 over the bore.

DougGuy
05-05-2019, 07:52 PM
That barrel has ZERO throat, so you can't even load boolits to spec in the load data or they won't chamber. That is also a hardened barrel which requires a carbide reamer to put any freebore in there. To be honest I think you would have better results with an aftermarket barrel if you can get one where you are.

Hickory
05-05-2019, 08:06 PM
I would try to increase bullet size first i usually go a full .001 to .002 over the bore.

Yes, I would try this first. A few thousands of an inch might be all you need.

williamhemmings
05-05-2019, 08:59 PM
Today I went to shoot the new boolits in my G17. Approximately after about 40 shots I started making keyholings.
The diameter is .3555, the slug of my glock is .355 and they are PC.
The armed bullet does not pass the plunk test satisfactorily, because if I do more crimp, I reduce its diameter. It falls well in the bedroom but does not rotate with the fingers.
Should I try to increase the diameter of my boolits? I think this week I got the expander that Lathesmith did to me, that I hope it's a help.
Or should I respect the plunk test?
Six months into this, I still can not find the way to be precise with this gun.
Inside barrel.
https://i.ibb.co/8zBS4pb/30208-DBC-6-D24-48-CB-B86-A-487-DE55-ADA3-E.jpg (https://ibb.co/YDWqTMX)
https://i.ibb.co/8zBS4pb/30208-DBC-6-D24-48-CB-B86-A-487-DE55-ADA3-E.jpg (https://ibb.co/YDWqTMX)
My boolit
https://i.ibb.co/X2cZP0G/A8-F625-C6-1-F99-4-A0-A-A5-F2-E5-A6848459-C3.jpg (https://ibb.co/YRH7SnV)Glock recommends not using lead bullets in their weapons.

Sent from my moto g(6) using Tapatalk

williamhemmings
05-05-2019, 09:04 PM
Today I went to shoot the new boolits in my G17. Approximately after about 40 shots I started making keyholings.
The diameter is .3555, the slug of my glock is .355 and they are PC.
The armed bullet does not pass the plunk test satisfactorily, because if I do more crimp, I reduce its diameter. It falls well in the bedroom but does not rotate with the fingers.
Should I try to increase the diameter of my boolits? I think this week I got the expander that Lathesmith did to me, that I hope it's a help.
Or should I respect the plunk test?
Six months into this, I still can not find the way to be precise with this gun.
Inside barrel.
https://i.ibb.co/8zBS4pb/30208-DBC-6-D24-48-CB-B86-A-487-DE55-ADA3-E.jpg (https://ibb.co/YDWqTMX)
https://i.ibb.co/8zBS4pb/30208-DBC-6-D24-48-CB-B86-A-487-DE55-ADA3-E.jpg (https://ibb.co/YDWqTMX)
My boolit
https://i.ibb.co/X2cZP0G/A8-F625-C6-1-F99-4-A0-A-A5-F2-E5-A6848459-C3.jpg (https://ibb.co/YRH7SnV)Also Glock Chambers are on the large size to facilitate chambering and some died (Dillion) size cases tight to facilitate chambering. This works the brass and can cause a Brite ring near the base. If reloaded to often the case can fail.

Sent from my moto g(6) using Tapatalk

Tom W.
05-05-2019, 09:52 PM
I shot that same boolit when I had my Glocks, a 17 and a 19, and still use it in my Ruger and CZ. I used a Lee .358 sizer and it barely touched the boolit, but the thing shot wonderfully.No leading in the Glock factory barrels, no FTF, stovepipes or anything. I knew that if I needed to shoot something the Glocks would go Boom. You do need to seat the boolit deeper. I saw your picture and looked at one of my loaded rounds and you have way too much side of the boolit showing. I seat mine to the end of the straight side and it does well. The others I'll size to .357 and they also do well, but right now I'm saving those for the CZ.

sigep1764
05-06-2019, 08:43 AM
Gents, if we look at the rifling in that barrel it is definitely not a stock Glock barrel. It has cut rifling.
Nueces, I would shorten the overall length and reduce the powder charge appropriately for the new length. I would also size before PC and load without sizing after PC. See where this leads you.

Sig556r
05-06-2019, 08:53 AM
You do need to seat the boolit deeper. I saw your picture and looked at one of my loaded rounds and you have way too much side of the boolit showing. I seat mine to the end of the straight side and it does well.
I think you mean the boolits needs to seat deeper so casemouth coincide with the start of the taper...

gnostic
05-06-2019, 09:29 AM
I've shot buckets of those 120 grain TC Lee bullets out of 3 or 4, 9mm pistols. Size them .358, lube with Lyman Super Moly, seat them a bit deeper and taper crimp. You didn't say where the bullet was contacting the barrel when you plunk test. Seat the bullet deep enough that it doesn't contact the barrel. Also, the loaded case in the photo still has a bit of flare from your expander die, use a taper crimp die to remove it...

atr
05-06-2019, 09:41 AM
Looks like your barrel is leading...try a larger diamenter

waksupi
05-06-2019, 10:49 AM
Seat the bullet deeper in the case.
Use a harder alloy.
Buy a Wolf bbl with conventional rifling.

Harder alloys are not a good thing for most handguns.

reddog81
05-06-2019, 11:11 AM
Sounds like a number of issues. Seat the bullets at the longest OAL that allows for them to fit the magazine, feed, and chamber with 100'% reliability. Just stick with loads closer to starting loads while trying to figure out the best OAL.

It looks like your powder coat is failing. Leading like that shouldn't happen with a correctly cured powder coat finish. Accuracy will drop off sharply once your barrel starts to lead.

A .356 or .357 sizing die will probably work better than a .3555 die, but unless you fix the PC problem it won;t make much difference,

cwlongshot
05-06-2019, 11:31 AM
Wow nueces5... answers all over the board!!

I also shoot a lot of cast out of Glocks, factory and AM barrels.

Since PCing I have been seeing great results. Most of my cast comp bullets are about 14 BHN and powder coat. I shot many thousands last season and the barrels are clean as a whistle! I have been using CLAYS powder for about 1050 ish fps. (Mine are 40, I don't do 9) T tell the honest truth, I have more issues with AM barrels with cast!!
Don't listen to the hype. Be smart keep the barrel clean, shoot PC properly coated and DONT WORRY! 10's of thousands of rounds over a couple years are how I know.

I agree, adj your OAL. hardness "requirements" change with velocity. I load softer (10-12) with some cast and still PC with no issues. BUT I don't push velocity, I strive for accuracy, IF that comes with velocity, I adjust as needed. For me, function and Accuracy are most important. Steel and paper don't complain much at how fast the bullet impacts them. GAME use changes things but I get the impression your talking target here.

Good luck,
CW

Tom W.
05-06-2019, 11:49 AM
I think you mean the boolits needs to seat deeper so casemouth coincide with the start of the taper...

Whatever. It was late last night. Anyway the COL looks too long......

dondiego
05-06-2019, 11:49 AM
Glock recommends not using lead bullets in their weapons.

Sent from my moto g(6) using Tapatalk

Glock also recommends to not use reloaded ammo as well. I have never had a problem with either.

Tom W.
05-06-2019, 02:56 PM
Almost all manufactures say not to use handloaded or reloaded ammo..... maybe because Bubba once loaded a .454 to the top with BE and made a compressed load....

Strtspdlx
05-06-2019, 03:39 PM
I would say you may need to seat the bullet deeper and reduce powder charge and that crimp looks to still be flared at the mouth. Take some calipers and measure just below the mouth and then measure the mouth and see if it still has flare. I usually fail the plubk test with cast because the bullet is engaging the rifling. And yours looks like it may. But without it and the barrel in hand i cant say certainly.

nueces5
05-06-2019, 04:15 PM
last night I made a couple of dummies, decreasing the oal, and now turns perfect in the bedroom.
Disarmed and measured, and has 3555
I'll wait for the lathesmith expander

JBinMN
05-06-2019, 07:30 PM
Just so some understand, Nueces5 is from Argentina, & English is "not" his first language.

The reason I mention that, is in case someone comes along & does not understand his use of the term, "bedroom", or other terms that do not translate "exactly".

In translation, "chamber", comes thru as "bedroom".

"Armed" round, means, "loaded" round, and "disarmed" round, means "unloaded" round.

I just thought I would mention that, so some do not give the man a "ration of ****", for the use of terms that are not quite understood by all due to translation difficulties.
;)
{ No , it has not happened yet, but I am trying to, "head things off at the pass.". ;) There are some who are..."That guy"... So, try not to be, "That guy". ;) }

I think it is pretty cool that someone from a country that does not share the same language, or does not fluently speak English, is taking the time to come here to CB.GL. forum for advice.
{Yes, I know that there are & have been others, but I still think it is pretty cool. How may others here that have English as a first language, have been going on to other countries forums that do not use English as a common language & ask for advice in "their language"? ;) Yep... Pretty cool in my book...}

Anyway.. Just thought I would mention it...
:)

nueces5
05-06-2019, 07:53 PM
Thanks JB! Let's add that I have a fever tonight, I can put anything and I will not notice

waksupi
05-07-2019, 11:53 AM
Just so some understand, Nueces5 is from Argentina, & English is "not" his first language.

The reason I mention that, is in case someone comes along & does not understand his use of the term, "bedroom", or other terms that do not translate "exactly".

In translation, "chamber", comes thru as "bedroom".

"Armed" round, means, "loaded" round, and "disarmed" round, means "unloaded" round.

I just thought I would mention that, so some do not give the man a "ration of ****", for the use of terms that are not quite understood by all due to translation difficulties.
;)
{ No , it has not happened yet, but I am trying to, "head things off at the pass.". ;) There are some who are..."That guy"... So, try not to be, "That guy". ;) }

I think it is pretty cool that someone from a country that does not share the same language, or does not fluently speak English, is taking the time to come here to CB.GL. forum for advice.
{Yes, I know that there are & have been others, but I still think it is pretty cool. How may others here that have English as a first language, have been going on to other countries forums that do not use English as a common language & ask for advice in "their language"? ;) Yep... Pretty cool in my book...}

Anyway.. Just thought I would mention it...
:)

I don't know current stats, but seem to recall CB had members from 26 countries as members.

JBinMN
05-07-2019, 12:45 PM
I don't know current stats, but seem to recall CB had members from 26 countries as members.

I think that is great!
:)

fredj338
05-07-2019, 02:51 PM
Is that am after market bbl? In stock glock bbls I run 0.357" bullets, lubed, HT or PC coated, always good accuracy & never a keyhole. In after market bbls, the bore us often a bit tighter so I can get by with 0.356".

cwlongshot
05-07-2019, 02:54 PM
Yes and the chamber will be tighter as well.

I have 4-5 aftermarket barrels. Reliability with cast is poor at best. With Jacketed they are nearly 100%!

Cw